通信作者标注制度研究
|
摘要
标注通信作者已是国际多数期刊的署名惯例。文章回顾我国通信作者研究历程,对我国CSSCI和CSCD来源期刊的通信作者标注情况进行调查分析,发现通信作者署名存在标注位置不统一、不同学科之间接受程度有差异、对通信作者的贡献认可程度不一等问题。在此基础上,文章讨论科学标注通信作者、合理分配其科研贡献、建立我国学术期刊通信作者制度的必要性。
Designating a corresponding author is a common practice in many international journals. This paper reviewed the research of corresponding authors in China and analyzed the corresponding authors in CSSCI and CSCD core journals. The results show that there are some problems with corresponding author indication. For example,the way to indicate corresponding authors by journals is not uniform. Furthermore,there is a significant difference in the acceptance of corresponding authors and the recognition for their contributions by different subject disciplines. On this basis,this paper discusses the necessity of establishing a corresponding author system,designating corresponding authors in a scientific way and duly acknowledging their contributions to research.
Designating a corresponding author is a common practice in many international journals. This paper reviewed the research of corresponding authors in China and analyzed the corresponding authors in CSSCI and CSCD core journals. The results show that there are some problems with corresponding author indication. For example,the way to indicate corresponding authors by journals is not uniform. Furthermore,there is a significant difference in the acceptance of corresponding authors and the recognition for their contributions by different subject disciplines. On this basis,this paper discusses the necessity of establishing a corresponding author system,designating corresponding authors in a scientific way and duly acknowledging their contributions to research.
引文
[1][16]Liu X Z,Fang H.Scientific group leaders’authorship preferences:an empirical investigation[M].Springer-Verlag:New York,2014.
[2][18]Mattsson P,Sundberg C J,Laget P.Is correspondence reflected in the author position?Abibliometric study of the relation between corresponding author and byline position[J].Scientometrics,2011,87(1):99-105.
[3]邹承鲁.只有立足国内才能提高我国科学的整体水平---论成果评价和评奖中存在的一些问题[N].中国科学报,1996-05-22.
[4]作者、第一作者、通讯作者、作者单位署名的界定[J].中国微创外科杂志,2009(5):447.
[5][10]金会平.科技期刊通讯作者署名权的法律解释及规范使用建议[J].科技与出版,2016(9):59-62.
[6]杨杰,沙勇.科技期刊附载作者简介的必要性[J].科技与出版,1998(4):31.
[7]李冰.正确标示通讯联系人[J].中国科技期刊研究,2000(2):77.
[8][21]周广礼,是雅蓓,夏爱红.高校学报宜对通讯作者进行简介[M]//华东地区高等院校自然科学学报编辑协会.学报编辑论丛(第十集).南昌:江西高校出版社,2002:202-203.
[9]孙丽娟.科技论文作者署名排序与通讯作者[J].中国科技期刊研究,2005(2):242-244.
[11]秦小川,方红玲,刘雪立.国内外生物医学期刊通讯作者标注情况的调查分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2010(6):786-789.
[12]王丽萍,李立,王卓青.医学期刊多通信作者的署名特点及分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2017(12):1110-1114.
[13]潘云,程曦,王国燕.2010-2015年我国Nature和Science成果分布的定量研究---基于中国第一作者及通讯作者的论文分析[J].科普研究,2016(6):33-39,101.
[14]我校求是特聘教授项春生以共同通讯作者在《自然:免疫学》杂志上发表论文[J].浙江大学学报(医学版),2008(3):299.
[15]谢小芳.理工大教授作为共同通讯作者在《Nature》发表研究成果[N].大连日报,2017-04-04(002).
[17]Wren J D,Kozak K Z,Johnson K R,et al.The write position:A survey of perceived contributions to papers based on byline position and number of authors[J].Embo Reports,2007,8(11):988-991.
[19]Zuckerman H A.Patterns of Name Ordering Among Authors of Scientific Papers:A Study of Social Symbolism and Its Ambiguity[J].American Journal of Sociology,1968,74(3):276-291.
[20]梁立明,刘俊婉.师生合作发表科技论文署名模式的研究与思考[J].自然辩证法通讯,2003(5):47-53,111.
[2][18]Mattsson P,Sundberg C J,Laget P.Is correspondence reflected in the author position?Abibliometric study of the relation between corresponding author and byline position[J].Scientometrics,2011,87(1):99-105.
[3]邹承鲁.只有立足国内才能提高我国科学的整体水平---论成果评价和评奖中存在的一些问题[N].中国科学报,1996-05-22.
[4]作者、第一作者、通讯作者、作者单位署名的界定[J].中国微创外科杂志,2009(5):447.
[5][10]金会平.科技期刊通讯作者署名权的法律解释及规范使用建议[J].科技与出版,2016(9):59-62.
[6]杨杰,沙勇.科技期刊附载作者简介的必要性[J].科技与出版,1998(4):31.
[7]李冰.正确标示通讯联系人[J].中国科技期刊研究,2000(2):77.
[8][21]周广礼,是雅蓓,夏爱红.高校学报宜对通讯作者进行简介[M]//华东地区高等院校自然科学学报编辑协会.学报编辑论丛(第十集).南昌:江西高校出版社,2002:202-203.
[9]孙丽娟.科技论文作者署名排序与通讯作者[J].中国科技期刊研究,2005(2):242-244.
[11]秦小川,方红玲,刘雪立.国内外生物医学期刊通讯作者标注情况的调查分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2010(6):786-789.
[12]王丽萍,李立,王卓青.医学期刊多通信作者的署名特点及分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2017(12):1110-1114.
[13]潘云,程曦,王国燕.2010-2015年我国Nature和Science成果分布的定量研究---基于中国第一作者及通讯作者的论文分析[J].科普研究,2016(6):33-39,101.
[14]我校求是特聘教授项春生以共同通讯作者在《自然:免疫学》杂志上发表论文[J].浙江大学学报(医学版),2008(3):299.
[15]谢小芳.理工大教授作为共同通讯作者在《Nature》发表研究成果[N].大连日报,2017-04-04(002).
[17]Wren J D,Kozak K Z,Johnson K R,et al.The write position:A survey of perceived contributions to papers based on byline position and number of authors[J].Embo Reports,2007,8(11):988-991.
[19]Zuckerman H A.Patterns of Name Ordering Among Authors of Scientific Papers:A Study of Social Symbolism and Its Ambiguity[J].American Journal of Sociology,1968,74(3):276-291.
[20]梁立明,刘俊婉.师生合作发表科技论文署名模式的研究与思考[J].自然辩证法通讯,2003(5):47-53,111.