微纳尺度多铁异质结中电驱动磁反转
|
摘要
近年来,多铁异质结中电控磁性研究引起了广泛关注,已成为多铁领域的热点.现代自旋电子学器件(如磁内存)通常利用电流产生的磁场或自旋转移扭矩效应驱动磁反转来实现数据擦写,但这带来高额能耗和热量,成为亟待解决的关键难题.而利用多铁异质结实施电场驱动磁反转则有望大幅降低能耗,从而实现高速、低能耗、高稳定性新型高密度磁存储、逻辑及其他自旋电子学器件.在当前器件发展的微型化趋势下,探索可集成化的微纳尺度电场驱动磁反转方案显得越发重要.本文针对发展新型磁电器件所面临的微型化关键问题,回顾了微纳尺度电场驱动磁反转研究的新进展,主要关注小尺度多铁异质结中电控磁的新特点、新方法及相关物理机理的实验和理论成果,讨论了进入纳米尺度将面临的挑战,并对未来研究工作提出一些展望.
Recently, there has been a surge of research interest in the electric field control of magnetism due to its promising application in spintronic and memory devices, which has become a hot topic in the field of multiferroic research. In current spintronic technology, magnetic reversal is usually driven by a large electric current via current generated magnetic field or spin-torque effect to write/erase a magnetic bit, and thus producing large power consumption and heat dissipation.While using insulating multiferroic materials, the reversal of magnetization can be triggered by applying an electric field instead of current, hence dramatically reducing the energy consumption and heat dissipation. With the current miniature trend in microelectronic technology, it is very essential to explore the electric field driven magnetic reversal(EFMS) behaviours in a micro/nanometer scale. In this article we briefly review the new progress in the field of EFMS based on multiferroic heterostructures, including some new features arising from size reduction, as well as some recent experimental and theoretical advances towards nanoscale EFMS, e.g. strain-mediated coupling, or spin exchange coupling in Bi Fe O3-based heterostructures, and their associated mechanisms. Finally, some key challenges in developing future EFMS based magnetoelectric devices, and some prospects for future research are also discussed.
Recently, there has been a surge of research interest in the electric field control of magnetism due to its promising application in spintronic and memory devices, which has become a hot topic in the field of multiferroic research. In current spintronic technology, magnetic reversal is usually driven by a large electric current via current generated magnetic field or spin-torque effect to write/erase a magnetic bit, and thus producing large power consumption and heat dissipation.While using insulating multiferroic materials, the reversal of magnetization can be triggered by applying an electric field instead of current, hence dramatically reducing the energy consumption and heat dissipation. With the current miniature trend in microelectronic technology, it is very essential to explore the electric field driven magnetic reversal(EFMS) behaviours in a micro/nanometer scale. In this article we briefly review the new progress in the field of EFMS based on multiferroic heterostructures, including some new features arising from size reduction, as well as some recent experimental and theoretical advances towards nanoscale EFMS, e.g. strain-mediated coupling, or spin exchange coupling in Bi Fe O3-based heterostructures, and their associated mechanisms. Finally, some key challenges in developing future EFMS based magnetoelectric devices, and some prospects for future research are also discussed.
引文
[1]Fiebig M 2005 J.Phys.D:Appl.Phys.38 R123
[2]Eerenstein W,Mathur N D,Scott J F 2006 Nature 442759
[3]Ramesh R,Spaldin N A 2007 Nature Mater.6 20
[4]Vaz C A F,Hoffman J,Ahn C H,Ramesh R 2010 Adv.Mater.22 2900
[5]Hu J M,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2016 Adv.Mater.28 15
[6]Song C,Cui B,Li F,Zhou X,Pan F 2017 Prog.Mater.Sci.87 33
[7]Ma J,Hu J,Li Z,Nan C W 2011 Adv.Mater.23 1062
[8]Wang K F,Liu J M,Ren Z F 2009 Adv.Phys.58 321
[9]Dong S,Liu J M,Cheong S W,Ren Z F 2015 Adv.Phys.64 519
[10]Vaz C A F 2012 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 24 333201
[11]Sun N X,Srinivasan G 2012 Spin(Singapore:World Scientific Publishing Company)2(03)1240004
[12]Taniyama T 2015 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 27 504001
[13]Worledgea D C,Hu G,Abraham D W,Sun J Z,Trouilloud P L,Nowak J,Brown S,Gaidis M C,O’Sullivan EJ,Robertazzi R P 2011 Appl.Phys.Lett.98 022501
[14]Katine J A,Fullerton E E 2008 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.320 1217
[15]Durlam M,Naji P J,Omair A,Durlam M,Naji P J,Omair A,De Herrera M,Calder J,Slaughter J M,Engel B N,Rizzo N D,Grynkewich G,Butcher B,Tracy C,Smith K,Kyler K W,Ren J J,Molla J A,Feil WA,Williams R G,Tehrani S 2003 IEEE J.Solid-State Circuits 38 769
[16]Liu L,Lee O J,Gudmundsen T J,Ralph D C,Buhrman R A 2012 Phys.Rev.Lett.109 096602
[17]Miron I M,Garello K,Gaudin G,Zermatten P J,Costache M V,Auffret S,Bandiera S,Rodmacq B,Schuhl A,Gambardella P 2011 Nature 476 189
[18]Hu J M,Li Z,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2011 Nat.Commun.2 553
[19]Barthélémy A,Bibes M 2008 Nature Mater.7 425
[20]Amiri P K,Alzate J G,Cai X Q,Ebrahimi F,Hu Y,Wong K,Grèzes C,Lee H,Yu G Q,Li X,Akyol M,Shao Q M,Katine J A,Langer J,Ocker B,Wang K L2015 IEEE Trans.Magn.5 1
[21]Zhou W,Xiong Y Q,Zhang Z M,Wang D H,Tan W S,Cao Q Q,Qian Z H,Du Y W 2016 ACS Appl.Mater.Interfaces 8 5424
[22]Kosub T,Kopte M,Hühne R,Appel P,Shields B,Maletinsky P,Hühne R,Liedke M O,Fassbender J,Schmidt O G,Makarov D 2017 Nat.Commun.8 13985
[23]Jaiswal A,Roy K 2017 Sci.Rep.7 39793
[24]Zheng R K,Li X G 2013 Prog.Phys.33 359(in Chinese)[郑仁奎,李晓光2013物理学进展33 359]
[25]Yang J J,Zhao Y G,Tian H F,Luo L B,Zhang H Y,He Y J,Luo H S 2009 Appl.Phys.Lett.94 212504
[26]Heron J T,Schlom D G,Ramesh R 2014 Appl.Phys.Rev.1 021303
[27]Weisheit M,Fahler S,Marty A,Souche Y,Poin C,Givord D 2007 Science 315 349
[28]Maruyama T,Shiota Y,Nozaki T,Ohta K,Toda N,Mizuguchi M,Tulapurkar A A,Shinjo T,Shiraishi M,Mizukami S,Ando Y,Suzuki Y 2009 Nat.Nanotechnol.4 158
[29]Molegraaf H J A,Hoffman J,Vaz C A F,Gariglio S,van der Marel D,Ahn C H,Triscone J M 2009 Adv.Mater.21 3470
[30]Nan C W 2015 Sci.Sin.:Tech.45 339(in Chinese)[南策文2015中国科学:技术科学45 339]
[31]Liu J M,Nan C W 2014 Physics 43 88(in Chinese)[刘俊明,南策文2014物理43 88]
[32]Duan C G 2009 Prog.Phys.3 215(in Chinese)[段纯刚2009物理学进展3 215]
[33]Yao X,Ma J,Lin Y,Nan C W,Zhang J 2015 Sci.China:Mater.58 143
[34]Gao X S,Zeng M,Liu J M 2014 Physics 43 246(in Chinese)[高兴森,曾敏,刘俊明2014物理43 246]
[35]Dong S,Liu J M 2010 Physics 39 714(in Chinese)[董帅,刘俊明2010物理39 714]
[36]Duan C G,Zhao Y G 2014 Physics 43 99(in Chinese)[段纯刚,赵永刚2014物理43 99]
[37]He H C,Lin Y H,Nan C W 2008 Chin.Sci.Bull.531136(in Chinese)[何泓材,林元华,南策文2008科学通报53 1136]
[38]Weiler M,Brandlmaier A,Gepr?gs S,Althammer M,Opel M,Bihler C,Huebl H,Brandt M S,Gross R,Goennenwein S T B 2009 New J.Phys.11 013021
[39]Xie Y,Ma J,Ganguly S,Ghosh A W 2017 J.Comput.Electron.16 1201
[40]Thiele C,D?rr K,Bilani O,R?del J,Schultz L 2007Phys.Rev.B 75 054408
[41]Venkataiah G,Shirahata Y,Itoh M,Taniyama T 2011Appl.Phys.Lett.99 102506
[42]Sander D 1999 Rep.Prog.Phys.62 809
[43]Pertsev N A 2008 Phys.Rev.B 78 212102
[44]Hu J M,Nan C W 2009 Phys.Rev.B 80 224416
[45]Hu J M,Nan C W,Chen L Q 2011 Phys.Rev.B 83134408
[46]Finizio S,Foerster M,Buzzi M,Krüger B,Jourdan M,Vaz C A,Hockel J,Miyawaki T,Tkach A,Valencia S,Kronast F,Carman G P,Nolting F,Kl?ui M 2014 Phys.Rev.Appl.1 021001
[47]Buzzi M,Chopdekar R V,Hockel J L,Bur A,Wu T,Pilet N,Warnicke P,Carman G P,Heyderman L J,Nolting F 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.111 027204
[48]Ba Y,Liu Y,Li P,Wu L,Unguris J,Pierce D T,Yang D,Feng C,Zhang Y,Wu H,Li D,Chang Y,Zhang JX,Han X F,Cai J W,Nan C W,Zhao Y G 2018 Adv.Funct.Mater.28 1706448
[49]Yang S W,Peng R C,Jiang T,Liu Y K,Feng L,Wang J J,Chen L Q,Li X G,Nan C W 2014 Adv.Mater.267091
[50]Ghidini M,Pellicelli R,Prieto J L,Moya X,Soussi J,Briscoe J,Dunn S,Mathur N D 2013 Nat.Commun.41453
[51]Li X,Carka D,Liang C Y,Sepulveda A E,Keller S M,Amiri P K,Carman G P,Lynch C S 2015 J.Appl.Phys.118 014101
[52]Gao Y,Hu J M,Wu L,Nan C W 2015 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 27 504005
[53]Hu J M,Yang T,Wang J,Huang H,Zhang J,Chen LQ,Nan C W 2015 Nano Lett.15 616
[54]Peng R C,Hu J M,Momeni K,Wang J J,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2016 Sci.Rep.6 27561
[55]Peng R C,Hu J M,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2017 NPG Asia Mater.9 e404
[56]Yi M,Xu B X,Müller R,Gross D 2017 Acta Mech.101007
[57]Preobrazhensky V,Klimov A,Tiercelin N,Duschb Y,Giordanob S,Churbanovd A,Mathurinb T,Pernodb P,Sigov A 2018 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.459 66
[58]Wang J J,Hu J M,Ma J,Zhang J X,Chen L Q,Nan CW 2014 Sci.Rep.4 7507
[59]Cui J,Keller S M,Liang C Y,Carman G P,Lynch C S2017 Nanotechnology 28 08LT01
[60]Salehi-Fashami M,D’Souza N 2017 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.438 76
[61]Cui J,Hockel J L,Nordeen P K,Pisani D M,Liang CY,Carman G P,Lynch C S 2013 Appl.Phys.Lett.103232905
[62]Biswas A K,Ahmad H,Atulasimha J,Bandyopadhyay S 2017 Nano Lett.17 3478
[63]Zhao T,Scholl A,Zavaliche F,Lee K,Barry M,Doran A,Cruz M P,Chu Y H,Ederer C,Spaldin N A,Das R R,Kim D M,Baek S H,Eom C B,Ramesh R 2006Nature Mater.5 823
[64]Martin L W,Chu Y H,Ramesh R 2010 Mater.Sci.Eng.68 89
[65]Martin L W,Chu Y H,Holcomb M B,Huijben M,Yu P,Han S J,Lee D,Wang S X,Ramesh R 2008 Nano Lett.8 2050
[66]Wu S M,Cybart S A,Yu P,Rossell M D,Zhang J X,Ramesh R,Dynes R C 2010 Nature Mater.9 756
[67]Popkov A F,Kulagin N E,Soloviov S V,Sukmanova K S,Gareeva Z V,Zvezdin A K 2015 Phys.Rev.B 92140414
[68]Elzo M,Moubah R,Blouzon C,Sacchi M,Grenier S,Belkhou R,Dhesi S,Colson D,Torres F,Kiwi M,Viret M,Jaouen N 2015 Phys.Rev.B 91 014402
[69]Chu Y H,Martin L W,Holcomb M B,Gajek M,Han S J,He Q,Balke N,Yang C H,Lee D,Hu W,Zhan Q,Yang P L,Arantxa F R,Scholl A,Wang S X,Ramesh R 2008 Nat.Mater.7 478
[70]Heron J T,Trassin M,Ashraf K,Gajek M,He Q,Yang S Y,Nikonov D E,Chu Y H,Salahuddin S,Ramesh R2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.107 217202
[71]Heron J T,Bosse J L,He Q,Gao Y,Trassin M,Ye L,Clarkson J D,Wang C,Liu J,Salahuddin S,Ralph DC,Schlom D G,Iniguez J,Huey B D,Ramesh R 2014Nature 516 370
[72]Zhou Z,Trassin M,Gao Y,Gao Y,Qiu D,Ashraf K,Nan T,Yang X,Bowden S R,Pierce D T,Stiles M D,Unguris J,Liu M,Howe B M,Brown G J,Salahuddin S,Ramesh R,Sun N X 2015 Nat.Commun.6 6082
[73]Wang J J,Hu J M,Yang T N,Wang,Feng M,Zhang JX,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2014 Sci.Rep.4 4553
[74]Wang J J,Hu J M,Peng R C,Gao Y,Shen Y,Chen LQ,Nan C W 2015 Sci.Rep.5 10459
[75]Saenrang W,Davidson B A,Maccherozzi F,Podkaminer J P,Irwin J,Johnson R D,Freeland J W,í?iguez J,Schad J L,Reierson K,Frederick J C,Vaz C A F,Howald L,Kim T H,Ryu S,Veenendaal M V,Radaelli P G,Dhesi S S,Rzchowski M S,Eom C B 2017 Nat.Commun.8 1583
[76]Tian G,Zhang F,Yao J,Fan H,Li P,Li Z,Song X,Zhang X,Qin M,Zeng M,Zhang Zh,Yao J,Gao X,Liu J 2016 ACS Nano.10 1025
[77]Yao J X,Song X,Gao X S,Tian G,Li P L,Fan H,Huang Z F,Yang W D,Chen D Y,Fan Z,Zeng M,Liu J M 2018 ACS Nano DOI:10.1021/acsnano.8b01936
[78]Yi M,Zhang H,Xu B X C 2017 npj Comput.Mater.338
[79]Bauer U,Yao L,Tan A J,Agrawal P,Emori S,Tuller H L,Dijken S,Beach G 2015 Nat.Mater.14 174
[80]Nawaoka K,Miwa S,Shiota Y,Mizuochi N,Suzuki Y2015 Appl.Phys.Express 8 063004
[81]Yang Q,Zhou Z,Wang L,Zhang H,Cheng Y,Hu Z,Peng B,Liu M 2018 Adv.Mater.30 1800449
[82]Gao Y,Hu J M,Nelson C T,Yang T N,Shen Y,Chen L Q,Ramesh R,Nan C W 2016 Sci.Rep.6 23696
[83]Hu J M,Yang T,Momeni K,Cheng X,Chen L,Lei S,Zhang S,Susan T M,Gopalan V,Carman G P,Nan CW,Chen L Q 2016 Nano Lett.16 2341
[84]Xiao Z,Conte R L,Chen C,Liang C Y,Sepulveda A,Bokor J,Carman G P,Candler R N 2018 Sci.Rep.85207
[85]Li Q,Tan A,Scholl A,Young A T,Yang M,Hwang C,Diaye A T N,Arenholz E,Li J,Qiu Z Q 2017 Appl.Phys.Lett.110 262405
[86]Shibata K,Iwasaki J,Kanazawa N,Aizawa S,Tanigaki T,Shirai M,Nakajima T,Kubota M,Kawasaki M,Park H S,Shindo D,Nagaosa N,Tokura Y 2015 Nat.Nanotechnol.10 589
[87]Upadhyaya P,Yu G,Amiri P K,Wang K L 2015 Phys.Rev.B 92 134411
[88]Zhang X,Zhou Y,Ezawa M,Zhao G P,Zhao W 2015Sci.Rep.5 11369
[89]Nakatani Y,Hayashi M,Kanai S,Fukami S,Ohno H2016 Appl.Phys.Lett.108 152403
[2]Eerenstein W,Mathur N D,Scott J F 2006 Nature 442759
[3]Ramesh R,Spaldin N A 2007 Nature Mater.6 20
[4]Vaz C A F,Hoffman J,Ahn C H,Ramesh R 2010 Adv.Mater.22 2900
[5]Hu J M,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2016 Adv.Mater.28 15
[6]Song C,Cui B,Li F,Zhou X,Pan F 2017 Prog.Mater.Sci.87 33
[7]Ma J,Hu J,Li Z,Nan C W 2011 Adv.Mater.23 1062
[8]Wang K F,Liu J M,Ren Z F 2009 Adv.Phys.58 321
[9]Dong S,Liu J M,Cheong S W,Ren Z F 2015 Adv.Phys.64 519
[10]Vaz C A F 2012 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 24 333201
[11]Sun N X,Srinivasan G 2012 Spin(Singapore:World Scientific Publishing Company)2(03)1240004
[12]Taniyama T 2015 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 27 504001
[13]Worledgea D C,Hu G,Abraham D W,Sun J Z,Trouilloud P L,Nowak J,Brown S,Gaidis M C,O’Sullivan EJ,Robertazzi R P 2011 Appl.Phys.Lett.98 022501
[14]Katine J A,Fullerton E E 2008 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.320 1217
[15]Durlam M,Naji P J,Omair A,Durlam M,Naji P J,Omair A,De Herrera M,Calder J,Slaughter J M,Engel B N,Rizzo N D,Grynkewich G,Butcher B,Tracy C,Smith K,Kyler K W,Ren J J,Molla J A,Feil WA,Williams R G,Tehrani S 2003 IEEE J.Solid-State Circuits 38 769
[16]Liu L,Lee O J,Gudmundsen T J,Ralph D C,Buhrman R A 2012 Phys.Rev.Lett.109 096602
[17]Miron I M,Garello K,Gaudin G,Zermatten P J,Costache M V,Auffret S,Bandiera S,Rodmacq B,Schuhl A,Gambardella P 2011 Nature 476 189
[18]Hu J M,Li Z,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2011 Nat.Commun.2 553
[19]Barthélémy A,Bibes M 2008 Nature Mater.7 425
[20]Amiri P K,Alzate J G,Cai X Q,Ebrahimi F,Hu Y,Wong K,Grèzes C,Lee H,Yu G Q,Li X,Akyol M,Shao Q M,Katine J A,Langer J,Ocker B,Wang K L2015 IEEE Trans.Magn.5 1
[21]Zhou W,Xiong Y Q,Zhang Z M,Wang D H,Tan W S,Cao Q Q,Qian Z H,Du Y W 2016 ACS Appl.Mater.Interfaces 8 5424
[22]Kosub T,Kopte M,Hühne R,Appel P,Shields B,Maletinsky P,Hühne R,Liedke M O,Fassbender J,Schmidt O G,Makarov D 2017 Nat.Commun.8 13985
[23]Jaiswal A,Roy K 2017 Sci.Rep.7 39793
[24]Zheng R K,Li X G 2013 Prog.Phys.33 359(in Chinese)[郑仁奎,李晓光2013物理学进展33 359]
[25]Yang J J,Zhao Y G,Tian H F,Luo L B,Zhang H Y,He Y J,Luo H S 2009 Appl.Phys.Lett.94 212504
[26]Heron J T,Schlom D G,Ramesh R 2014 Appl.Phys.Rev.1 021303
[27]Weisheit M,Fahler S,Marty A,Souche Y,Poin C,Givord D 2007 Science 315 349
[28]Maruyama T,Shiota Y,Nozaki T,Ohta K,Toda N,Mizuguchi M,Tulapurkar A A,Shinjo T,Shiraishi M,Mizukami S,Ando Y,Suzuki Y 2009 Nat.Nanotechnol.4 158
[29]Molegraaf H J A,Hoffman J,Vaz C A F,Gariglio S,van der Marel D,Ahn C H,Triscone J M 2009 Adv.Mater.21 3470
[30]Nan C W 2015 Sci.Sin.:Tech.45 339(in Chinese)[南策文2015中国科学:技术科学45 339]
[31]Liu J M,Nan C W 2014 Physics 43 88(in Chinese)[刘俊明,南策文2014物理43 88]
[32]Duan C G 2009 Prog.Phys.3 215(in Chinese)[段纯刚2009物理学进展3 215]
[33]Yao X,Ma J,Lin Y,Nan C W,Zhang J 2015 Sci.China:Mater.58 143
[34]Gao X S,Zeng M,Liu J M 2014 Physics 43 246(in Chinese)[高兴森,曾敏,刘俊明2014物理43 246]
[35]Dong S,Liu J M 2010 Physics 39 714(in Chinese)[董帅,刘俊明2010物理39 714]
[36]Duan C G,Zhao Y G 2014 Physics 43 99(in Chinese)[段纯刚,赵永刚2014物理43 99]
[37]He H C,Lin Y H,Nan C W 2008 Chin.Sci.Bull.531136(in Chinese)[何泓材,林元华,南策文2008科学通报53 1136]
[38]Weiler M,Brandlmaier A,Gepr?gs S,Althammer M,Opel M,Bihler C,Huebl H,Brandt M S,Gross R,Goennenwein S T B 2009 New J.Phys.11 013021
[39]Xie Y,Ma J,Ganguly S,Ghosh A W 2017 J.Comput.Electron.16 1201
[40]Thiele C,D?rr K,Bilani O,R?del J,Schultz L 2007Phys.Rev.B 75 054408
[41]Venkataiah G,Shirahata Y,Itoh M,Taniyama T 2011Appl.Phys.Lett.99 102506
[42]Sander D 1999 Rep.Prog.Phys.62 809
[43]Pertsev N A 2008 Phys.Rev.B 78 212102
[44]Hu J M,Nan C W 2009 Phys.Rev.B 80 224416
[45]Hu J M,Nan C W,Chen L Q 2011 Phys.Rev.B 83134408
[46]Finizio S,Foerster M,Buzzi M,Krüger B,Jourdan M,Vaz C A,Hockel J,Miyawaki T,Tkach A,Valencia S,Kronast F,Carman G P,Nolting F,Kl?ui M 2014 Phys.Rev.Appl.1 021001
[47]Buzzi M,Chopdekar R V,Hockel J L,Bur A,Wu T,Pilet N,Warnicke P,Carman G P,Heyderman L J,Nolting F 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.111 027204
[48]Ba Y,Liu Y,Li P,Wu L,Unguris J,Pierce D T,Yang D,Feng C,Zhang Y,Wu H,Li D,Chang Y,Zhang JX,Han X F,Cai J W,Nan C W,Zhao Y G 2018 Adv.Funct.Mater.28 1706448
[49]Yang S W,Peng R C,Jiang T,Liu Y K,Feng L,Wang J J,Chen L Q,Li X G,Nan C W 2014 Adv.Mater.267091
[50]Ghidini M,Pellicelli R,Prieto J L,Moya X,Soussi J,Briscoe J,Dunn S,Mathur N D 2013 Nat.Commun.41453
[51]Li X,Carka D,Liang C Y,Sepulveda A E,Keller S M,Amiri P K,Carman G P,Lynch C S 2015 J.Appl.Phys.118 014101
[52]Gao Y,Hu J M,Wu L,Nan C W 2015 J.Phys.:Condens.Matter 27 504005
[53]Hu J M,Yang T,Wang J,Huang H,Zhang J,Chen LQ,Nan C W 2015 Nano Lett.15 616
[54]Peng R C,Hu J M,Momeni K,Wang J J,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2016 Sci.Rep.6 27561
[55]Peng R C,Hu J M,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2017 NPG Asia Mater.9 e404
[56]Yi M,Xu B X,Müller R,Gross D 2017 Acta Mech.101007
[57]Preobrazhensky V,Klimov A,Tiercelin N,Duschb Y,Giordanob S,Churbanovd A,Mathurinb T,Pernodb P,Sigov A 2018 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.459 66
[58]Wang J J,Hu J M,Ma J,Zhang J X,Chen L Q,Nan CW 2014 Sci.Rep.4 7507
[59]Cui J,Keller S M,Liang C Y,Carman G P,Lynch C S2017 Nanotechnology 28 08LT01
[60]Salehi-Fashami M,D’Souza N 2017 J.Magn.Magn.Mater.438 76
[61]Cui J,Hockel J L,Nordeen P K,Pisani D M,Liang CY,Carman G P,Lynch C S 2013 Appl.Phys.Lett.103232905
[62]Biswas A K,Ahmad H,Atulasimha J,Bandyopadhyay S 2017 Nano Lett.17 3478
[63]Zhao T,Scholl A,Zavaliche F,Lee K,Barry M,Doran A,Cruz M P,Chu Y H,Ederer C,Spaldin N A,Das R R,Kim D M,Baek S H,Eom C B,Ramesh R 2006Nature Mater.5 823
[64]Martin L W,Chu Y H,Ramesh R 2010 Mater.Sci.Eng.68 89
[65]Martin L W,Chu Y H,Holcomb M B,Huijben M,Yu P,Han S J,Lee D,Wang S X,Ramesh R 2008 Nano Lett.8 2050
[66]Wu S M,Cybart S A,Yu P,Rossell M D,Zhang J X,Ramesh R,Dynes R C 2010 Nature Mater.9 756
[67]Popkov A F,Kulagin N E,Soloviov S V,Sukmanova K S,Gareeva Z V,Zvezdin A K 2015 Phys.Rev.B 92140414
[68]Elzo M,Moubah R,Blouzon C,Sacchi M,Grenier S,Belkhou R,Dhesi S,Colson D,Torres F,Kiwi M,Viret M,Jaouen N 2015 Phys.Rev.B 91 014402
[69]Chu Y H,Martin L W,Holcomb M B,Gajek M,Han S J,He Q,Balke N,Yang C H,Lee D,Hu W,Zhan Q,Yang P L,Arantxa F R,Scholl A,Wang S X,Ramesh R 2008 Nat.Mater.7 478
[70]Heron J T,Trassin M,Ashraf K,Gajek M,He Q,Yang S Y,Nikonov D E,Chu Y H,Salahuddin S,Ramesh R2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.107 217202
[71]Heron J T,Bosse J L,He Q,Gao Y,Trassin M,Ye L,Clarkson J D,Wang C,Liu J,Salahuddin S,Ralph DC,Schlom D G,Iniguez J,Huey B D,Ramesh R 2014Nature 516 370
[72]Zhou Z,Trassin M,Gao Y,Gao Y,Qiu D,Ashraf K,Nan T,Yang X,Bowden S R,Pierce D T,Stiles M D,Unguris J,Liu M,Howe B M,Brown G J,Salahuddin S,Ramesh R,Sun N X 2015 Nat.Commun.6 6082
[73]Wang J J,Hu J M,Yang T N,Wang,Feng M,Zhang JX,Chen L Q,Nan C W 2014 Sci.Rep.4 4553
[74]Wang J J,Hu J M,Peng R C,Gao Y,Shen Y,Chen LQ,Nan C W 2015 Sci.Rep.5 10459
[75]Saenrang W,Davidson B A,Maccherozzi F,Podkaminer J P,Irwin J,Johnson R D,Freeland J W,í?iguez J,Schad J L,Reierson K,Frederick J C,Vaz C A F,Howald L,Kim T H,Ryu S,Veenendaal M V,Radaelli P G,Dhesi S S,Rzchowski M S,Eom C B 2017 Nat.Commun.8 1583
[76]Tian G,Zhang F,Yao J,Fan H,Li P,Li Z,Song X,Zhang X,Qin M,Zeng M,Zhang Zh,Yao J,Gao X,Liu J 2016 ACS Nano.10 1025
[77]Yao J X,Song X,Gao X S,Tian G,Li P L,Fan H,Huang Z F,Yang W D,Chen D Y,Fan Z,Zeng M,Liu J M 2018 ACS Nano DOI:10.1021/acsnano.8b01936
[78]Yi M,Zhang H,Xu B X C 2017 npj Comput.Mater.338
[79]Bauer U,Yao L,Tan A J,Agrawal P,Emori S,Tuller H L,Dijken S,Beach G 2015 Nat.Mater.14 174
[80]Nawaoka K,Miwa S,Shiota Y,Mizuochi N,Suzuki Y2015 Appl.Phys.Express 8 063004
[81]Yang Q,Zhou Z,Wang L,Zhang H,Cheng Y,Hu Z,Peng B,Liu M 2018 Adv.Mater.30 1800449
[82]Gao Y,Hu J M,Nelson C T,Yang T N,Shen Y,Chen L Q,Ramesh R,Nan C W 2016 Sci.Rep.6 23696
[83]Hu J M,Yang T,Momeni K,Cheng X,Chen L,Lei S,Zhang S,Susan T M,Gopalan V,Carman G P,Nan CW,Chen L Q 2016 Nano Lett.16 2341
[84]Xiao Z,Conte R L,Chen C,Liang C Y,Sepulveda A,Bokor J,Carman G P,Candler R N 2018 Sci.Rep.85207
[85]Li Q,Tan A,Scholl A,Young A T,Yang M,Hwang C,Diaye A T N,Arenholz E,Li J,Qiu Z Q 2017 Appl.Phys.Lett.110 262405
[86]Shibata K,Iwasaki J,Kanazawa N,Aizawa S,Tanigaki T,Shirai M,Nakajima T,Kubota M,Kawasaki M,Park H S,Shindo D,Nagaosa N,Tokura Y 2015 Nat.Nanotechnol.10 589
[87]Upadhyaya P,Yu G,Amiri P K,Wang K L 2015 Phys.Rev.B 92 134411
[88]Zhang X,Zhou Y,Ezawa M,Zhao G P,Zhao W 2015Sci.Rep.5 11369
[89]Nakatani Y,Hayashi M,Kanai S,Fukami S,Ohno H2016 Appl.Phys.Lett.108 152403