用户名: 密码: 验证码:
长距离输水工程防洪风险与投资优化问题的研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
长距离输水工程沿途往往要跨越众多河系,极易受到洪水的冲击,这就需要对其综合水毁风险给出定量的评估。本文以可靠度理论为基础,根据渠道所经过的各条河流的水文、地质、地形、工程结构的随机特征,给出了引水工程交叉建筑物的综合水毁风险计算方法。并以南水北调中线工程河北省段为例,对该方法进行了应用。本文的创新点主要有五个方面:
     1、本文以可靠度理论为基础,根据渠道所经过的各条河流的水文、地质、地形、工程结构的随机特征,给出了引水工程交叉建筑物的综合水毁风险计算方法。
     2、本文探讨了二维Gumbel分布模型,给出了其经验频率和理论频率的计算方法,并建立了其联合重现期和条件重现期的分布模型。它可以给出不同程度暴雨和径流遭遇组合的频率,也可以在一定的降雨量条件下给出不同径流量的发生频率,或一定的径流量条件下给出不同降雨量的发生频率。这对于解决与风险有关的多因素影响下的水文计算问题是非常有用的。
     3、现有的水毁风险评价方法只能从水文要素的角度考察单个交叉建筑物的水毁风险。本文提出通过计算Ditlevsen界限的方法,将求解n维分布函数的难题转化为求解二维分布函数,并据此给出了串联系统引水工程交叉建筑物的综合水毁风险,解决了多维风险组合计算的这一难题。
     4、传统的水工建筑物防洪设计标准不是真正意义上的建筑物防洪风险。这是因为现有的洪水频率计算方法是以年最大流量进行独立抽样。事实上河流一年内的洪水过程有时不止一次,很多情况下某一年的第二大洪峰流量比另一年的第一大洪峰流量还大。以年最大流量进行独立抽样作风险评价,忽略了年内其他的洪水信息。本文基于时变动力可靠度原理,将洪水作为随机过程考察,充分利用已有的洪水信息,给出了真正意义上的水工建筑物在设计有效期内的防洪风险估算模型。
     5、南水北调中线工程是长距离串联系统,工程的防洪风险较大,投资规模巨大。如何在结构可靠度与工程造价这对矛盾体中寻求最佳组合,往往是工程规划关注的焦点。本文将以可靠度理论为基础,通过考虑随机因素的随机特征,建立长距离输水工程交叉建筑物的综合可靠度估算方法并通过优化算法探讨了南水北调中线工程河北段12座渡槽形成的串联系统的整体可靠度与工程造价的最优分配问题。
It is very often that long distance water transfer engineering was destroyed by flood due to too many rivers to cross. So synthese flood risk analysis is needed. According to stochastic characteristics of hydrology, geology, geograghy and structure, we present synthese flood risk assessment method of crossing structures along water transfering engineering based on realibility analysis theory. The method was applied in South to North Water Transfer Project Middle Route in Hebei province. Results show that the flood risk of the system is between 4.6% to 1.5%,the average risk is about 3.1%. The break points in this thesis are following:
     1. According to stochastic characteristics of hydrology, geology, geograghy and structure, synthese flood risk assessment method of crossing structures along South to North Water Transfer Projcet Middle Route was established based on realibility analysis theory.
     2. This paper proposes the use of the two-dimension Gumbel mixed model, the bivariate extreme value distribution model with Gumbel marginals,to analyze the joint probability distribution of two hydrology stochastic variables. Based on the marginal distributions of these random variables, the joint distributions, the conditional probability functions, and the associated return periods are derived. It is helpful to solve the multi-variations hydrology problem.
     3. Traditional flood risk assessment method only appropriate to one river from hydrology view. This thesis establishing risk assessment model of long distance series system with Ditlevsen boundary and two dimensions Gumbel mixed model to avoid the nightmare of establishment of n-dimenssions joint probability distribution. The flood risk of South to North Water Transfer Project Middle Route in Hebei province is calculated as an example.
     4. Traditional flood risk assessment method is not real flood risk assessment. It is because traditional flood risk assessment method is based on annual maximum flow sample. But there is not only one flood process in one year. So it is often that second maximum flow in one year is larger than that of other year. Traditional method neglect many other hydrology information. The real flood risk assessment model is established on the base of time and spatial varying load reliability principle to make full ues of flood information.
     5. Crossing Structure Reliability of Water Transfer Project is determined by stochastic characteristics of hydrology, material, geology and structure. All of these aspects impact cost of engineering indirectly or directly. How to resolve the dilemma between cost and reliability is focus in engineering planning phase. This thesis present relation between cost and reliability of Water Transfer Project and optimize the engineering cost under the restriction of engineering reliability.
引文
[1]刘宁,贾超.基于可靠度的工程风险决策初探.岩土力学,2004,25(8):1297-1301
    [2]Alfredo.H.S.Ang Wilson H.Tang, Probability concepts in engineering planning and design Volume I, John Wiley & Sons, 1990
    [3]孙芳垂等译. Alfredo H.一&Ang Wilson H.Tang著.工程规划与设计中的概率概念,第Ⅱ卷北京:冶金工业出版社,1991
    [4]北京奥尔多投资研究中心编.风险不确定性与秩序.北京中国财政经济出版社, 2000:3-5
    [5]王春风.金融市场风险管理.天津:天津大学出版社,2001:1-4
    [6]A.H.S.Ang, Determination of optimal target reliability for design and upgrading of structures. Structural Safety 1997,19(1):91-103,
    [7]H.N.Cho, A.H.S.Ang,LK.Lim, Cost-effective optimal target reliability for seismic design and upgrading of long span PC bridges,Applications of statistics and probability, Melchers&Stewart 2000:519-526
    [8]言茂松.贝叶斯风险决策工程.北京:清华大学出版社,1989
    [9]Aleksander Rado, Consideration of the serviceability limit state in a time, dependent probabilistic cost model Application of statistics and probability, Balbnen, Rotterdam, 2000:605-612
    [10]Yasuhiro Mori, Bruce R.Ellingwood, Maintaining Reliability of Concrete Structures. I:Role of Inspection/Repair.journal of structural Engineering, 1994 ,120(3):824-845
    [11]Yasuhiro Mori, Bruce R. Elingwood. Maintaining Reliability of Concrete Structures.Ⅲ: Optimumn Inspection/Repair. Journal of structural Engineering,1994 ,120(3):846-862
    [12]Yasuhiro Mori, Bruce R, Reliability-Based Service-Life Assessment of Aging Concrete Structures. Journal of structural Engineering,1993,119,(5):1600-1621
    [13]程耿东,李刚,基于功能的结构抗震设计中一些问题的探讨.建筑结构学报. 2000,21(1):5-11
    [14]李国强,基于概率可靠度进行结构抗展设计的若干理论问题建筑结构学报,2000,21(1):12-16
    [15]Frangopol.D.M. Sreuctual optimization using reliability concepts. Journal of structural Engineering. ASCE. 1985. 11(1):288-301
    [16]Rosenblueth.E Towards optimum design through building codes. Journal of Structual Dicision.Proc.ASCE 1976.10(2):591-607
    [17]Applied Technology Council. Earthquake damage evaluation data for California ATC-13. Redwood City California.1985
    [18]A.H.S.Ang, Determination of optimal target reliability for design and upgrading of structures. Structural safety 1997,19 (1):91-103
    [19]王光远工程结构软设计理论,北京:科学出版社,1995
    [20]Jun Kanda, Engineering role in failure cost evaluation for building, Structure Safety 1997,19 (1):79-90
    [21]David G.Elms, Risk balancing in structural problems structural safety 1997.19 ,(1): 67-77
    [22]Yasuhiro Mori. Reliability-based service-life assessment of aging concrete structures Journal of structural Engineering 1993, 119 (5):1600-1619
    [23]Franklin.Y.Cheng, A.H.-S.Ang, Cost-efectiveness optimization for aseismic design criteria of RC buildings, New York press,1997:13-25
    [24]Vanmarke E, Random Fields: Analysis and Synthesis Cambridge: MIT Press,1983:40-90
    [25]刘宁,郑建青,工程随机力学与工程可靠性中的若干问题(上)河海大学学报,1999.27(5):1-9
    [26]刘宁,工程随机力学与工程可靠性中的若干问题(下),河海大学学报.2000.28(1):1-9
    [27]吴世伟,张思俊,余强坝水位变化规律及统计量.,吴世伟,结构安全度与可靠度分析论文集南京:河海大学出版社,1988:51-59
    [28]刘宁,刘光廷.大体积混凝土结构温度场的随机有限元算法.清华大学学报,1996.36(1):41-47
    [29]刘俊生,尾矿坝随机渗流研究及其在可靠度分析中的应用,[硕士学位论文].南京:河海大学.1995
    [30]包承纲,高大钊,张庆华.地基工程可靠度方法研究.武汉:武汉测绘大学出版社,1997:1-18
    [31]杨杰等.几何形状随机结构的有限元分析.固体力学学报.1999.20 (专集): 268-272
    [32]Cunnane, C. Review of statistical models for flood frequency estimation. In: Singh, V.P. Hydrologic Frequency Modelling, Reidel: Dordrecht, 1987:49–95..
    [33]Ben Chie Yen, Discussion of "Predicting Ground-water Response to Precipitation" ASCE, Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 1986,112, (3):382-385
    [34]Plate.E.J, J.Ihringer,“Failure Probability of Flood Levees on a Tidal River”in B.C.Yen, ed.,Stochastic and Risk Analysis in Hydraulic Engineering,Water Resources Publications, 1986:48-58
    [35]Meon,G.,“Overtopping Probability of Dams under Flood Load”, in J.T.Kuo and G.F.Lin, eds, Stochastic Hydraulics 92, Proceedings of 6th IAHR International Symposium, Taipei, Water Resources Publications, 1992:99-106
    [36]Mays.L.W ed, Reliability Analysis of Water Distribution Systems, ASCE, New York,1989:121-126
    [37]Johnson.P.A,“Reliability based Pier Sour Engineering,”Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 1992,118(10):1344-1358,
    [38]Chang.C.H, Y.K.Tung, J.C. Yang,“Monte Carlo Simulation for Correlated Variables with Marginal Distributions,”Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 1994, 120 (2): 313-331
    [39]Yixing Bao, Larry W. Mays, Model for Water Distribution System Reliability ,Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 1990, 116, (9):119-113
    [40]Mizumura.K., D.Ouazar,“Stochastic Characteristics of Open Channel Flow,”J. K. Kuo and G.F.Lin, Stochastic Hydraulics 92, Proceedings of 6th IAHR International Symposium, Taipei, Water Resources Publications, 1992
    [41]Cheng.S.T, B.C.Yen, W.H.Tang,“Sensitivity of Risk Evaluation to Coefficient of Variation,”in B.C.Yen, Stochastic and Risk Analysis in Hydraulic Engineering, Water Resources Publications, 1986:266-273
    [42]Johannes K. Vrijling,“Development in Probabilistic Design of Flood Defenses in the Netherlands”, in B.C.Yen, Y.K.Tung, Reliability and Uncertainty Analyses in Hydraulic Design, ASCE,1993:133-178
    [43]Johannes.K.Vrijling,“Probabilistic Design of Water Retaining Structures,”in L.Duckstein and E.J.Plate,eds., Engineering Reliability and Risk in Water Resources, Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1987:115-134
    [44]Ben Chie Yen, C.S.Melching,“Reliability Analysis Methods for Sediment Problems,”Proceeding, 5th Federal Interagency Sediment Conference, Las Vegas, 1991:91-98
    [45]Wilson.H.Tang, Ben.Chie.Yen,“Dam Safty Inspection Scheduling”,Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 1991,117(2):214-229,
    [46]Wilson.H.Tang, Ben Chie Yen, Larry.W.Mays,“Optimal Risk-Based Design of Storm Sewer Networks”,Journal of the Environmental Engineering Division, 1975, 101, (3):381-398
    [47]Ben Chie Yen and Wilson H. Tang,“Risk-Safety Factor Relation for Storm Sewer Design”Journal of the Environmental Engineering Division, 1976, 102, (2):509-516
    [48]B.C.Yen,“Safty Factor in Hydrologic and Hydraulic Design of Culverts”,in E.A.McBean, K.W.Hipel and T.E.Unny, Reliability Analysis in Water Resources Management, Littleton, Colo.,Water Resources Publications, 1986:215-230
    [49]Yeou-Koung Tung, Larry W. Mays,“Risk Analysis for Hydraulic Design”,Journal of the Hydraulics Division, 1980,106(5):893-913
    [50]Yeou-Koung Tung, Larry W. Mays,“Risk Models for Levee Design”, Water Resources Research, 1981,17(4):833-841,
    [51]Han-Lin Lee, Larry W. Mays,“Hydraulic Uncertainties in Flood Levee Capacity”Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 1986, 112,(10):928-934
    [52]McBean.E.A, J.Penel, K.L.Siu,“Uncertainties Analysis of a Delineated Floodplain”,Canadian Journal of Civil Engineers, 1984(11):387-395.
    [53]Huang, Stochastic and Risk Analysis in Hydraulic Engineering, B.C.Yen, Water Resources Publications, Littleton, Colo., 1986:48-58
    [54]The 20’s International Congress Of the Large Dams (ICOLD) Special Question 76
    [55]梁在朝,李泰来.江河防洪能力的风险分析,长江科学院院报,2001, 18(2): 7-10
    [56]李清富,江见鲸对防洪系统可靠性基本问题的探讨,灾害学,1994, 9(4): 14-18
    [57]李青云,张建民.长江堤防工程风险分析和安全评价初论,中国软科学,2001, 4(11) :112-115
    [58]李青云,长江堤防工程安全评价的理论和方法研究,清华大学博士论文,2002
    [59]刘宁,可靠度随机有限元法及其工程应用,北京:中国水利水电出版社,2001
    [60]董聪,现代结构系统可靠性理论及其应用,北京:科学出版社,2001
    [61]吴世伟,结构可靠度分析北京,人民交通出版社,1990
    [62]Palle Thoft-Christensen and Michael J.Baker Structure Reliability Theory and Its Applications Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York,1992
    [63]Palle Thoft-Christensen and Murotsu.Y, Application of Structure Systems Reliability Theory.Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York,1986
    [64]Gollwitzer.S, Rackwitz.R, Equivalent components in first-order system reliability. Reliability Engineering.1993.5:271-280
    [65]Moses.F, New direction and research needs in system reliability research,Structure Safety,1990,12,(7):93-100
    [66]Richard.M.Bennet, Structure Analysis Methods for System Reliability, Structure Safety,1990,12(7) :47-51
    [67]Norbert Kuschel, Rtldiger Rachwitz, Optimal design under time-variant reliability constraints.Structure Safety,2000, 22 (2):113-127
    [68]Hohenbichler.M & Rackwitz R, Improvement of Second-order Reliability estimation by importance samples, Journalof Engineering Mechanics, ASCE,1990,116:1183-1197
    [69]Thoft-Christensen.P, Sorensen J D , Reliability of Structures ystem with correlated elements,Applied Math Modeling, 1982.6: 171-177
    [70]Ditlevsen O, Narrow Reliability Bounds for Structure System, J.Struct. Mech.,1979, 7(5):453-472
    [71]Feng Y S, A Method of Computing Structure System Reliability with High Accuracy, Computers and Structures,1989,33 (1):1-5
    [72]Ditlevsen O, Generalized Second Moment Reliability Index, Struct. Mech.,1979, 7:435-451
    [73]Ditlevsen O, Taylor Expansion of Series System Reliability, Struct. Mech. 1984, 110(2):293-307
    [74]Ditlevsen O, System reliability bounding by conditioning, Journal of Engineering Mechanics Division,1982, 108(5):708-718
    [75]Philippe Maincon. A first order reliability method for series systems, Structural Safety, 2000, 22 (1)
    [76]Weicheng Cui, On the Bound for Structure System Reliability, Structure Safety,1991,13(9)
    [77]Hohenbichler.M, Rackwitz.R, Sensitivity and importance measures in structural reliability, Civil Eng System,1986
    [78]L.德克斯坦, E.J.勃兰特.水资源工程可靠性与风险,吴媚玲,王俊德译.北京:水利电力出版社,1993
    [79]杨百银,王锐深,安占刚,水库泄洪方案布置可靠性分析和风险分析,水力发电, 1996: 54-59
    [80]吴媚玲,姚翅武.重力坝的应力稳定与可靠性.北京:中国科学技术出版社,1990
    [81]陈进,黄薇.重力坝系统可靠度研究方法探讨.长江科学院院报,1997, 14 (1): 21-24
    [82]武清玺,吴世伟,吕泰仁重力坝可靠度分析的随机有限元法,水利学报, 1990,21(1):
    [83]吴世伟,用随机有限元法分析重力坝的失效模式及系统可靠度.工程结构可靠性(中国土木工程学会桥梁及结构学会全国第二届学术交流会议论文集),1989
    [84]朱元生,王道席水库安全设计与垮坝风险,水利水电科技进展,1995,15(1): 17-24
    [85]吴世伟,张思俊,余强坝上游水位变化规律及统计量见吴世伟主编,结构安全度与可靠度分析论文集.河海大学出版社.1988:51-59
    [86]吴世伟用验证荷载法校核重力坝的可靠度应用力学学报,1986.12(1): 57-64
    [87]王东,陈建康重力坝可靠度参数敏感性探讨四川大学学报(工程科学版), 2001, 33(4): 1-5
    [88]张俊芝,李桂青服役重力坝系统可靠性分析及概率寿命探讨,水利学报,2000,31,(4):40-45
    [89]Faravelli.L, A response surface approach for reliability analysis. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, ASCE, 1989, 115(12):112-125
    [90]Bucher.C.G, Bourgund.U, A fast and efficient response surface approach for structural reliability problems, Structural Safety,1990,12(1):116-119
    [91]贡金鑫,赵国藩串联结构体系可靠度的二元泰勒级数展开,计算力学学报,1997,14(1):78-84
    [92]贡金鑫,赵国藩串联结构体系可靠度的一个实用算法.中国土木工程学会桥梁及结构工程学会结构可靠度委员会工程结构可靠性全国第四届学术交流会议论文集.北京:地质出版社,1995:34-41
    [93]董聪,冯元生.枚举结构系统主要失效模式的一种新算法.航空学报, 1991,12(9):537-541
    [94]姚卫星,顾怡.用自动矩阵力法枚举结构的主要失效模式.计算结构力学及其应用,1996,13(1):62-66
    [95]张云阁,姚卫星结构系统主要失效模式的枚举,强度与环境,1997,24(1):1-11
    [96]伍朝晖,赵国藩数论方法在结构体系可靠度计算中的应用.大连理工大学学报,1998,38,(1):92-96
    [97]张思俊,吴世伟,吴泰仁,拱坝重力墩抗滑稳定可靠度分析.结构安全度与可靠度分析论文集南京:河海大学出版社,1988
    [98]武清玺,基于有限元的重力坝可靠度分析,河海大学学报,1987,15(5):78-81
    [99]陈进,黄薇.重力坝系统可靠度研究方法探讨,长江科学院院报,1997,14(1):21-28
    [100]李正农等.洛河渡槽抗震可靠度分析,中国农村水利水电,2000,31,(11):29-30
    [101]贾超,刘宁,陈进,程卫帅,南水北调中线工程渡槽结构风险分析,水力发电. 2003,29,(7):23-27
    [102]雷杰某预应力排水渡槽结构设计及可靠度分析研究.浙江大学工学硕士论文,2003
    [103]Rackwize.R, Practical Probabilistic Approach to Design, Bulletin 112, Comite European du Beton, Paris, 1976
    [104]Cunnane.C, Review of statistical models for flood frequency estimation. In: Singh, V.P. Hydrologic Frequency Modelling, Reidel: Dordrecht,1987: 49–95
    [105]郑红星,刘昌明.南水北调东中两线不同水文区降水丰枯遭遇性分析地理学报, 2000,31(5):523-532
    [106]冯平,崔广涛,胡明罡.暴雨洪水共同作用下的多变量防洪计算问题水利学报, 2000,31(2):49-53
    [107]冯平,闫大鹏,耿六成等.南水北调东中线总干渠防洪风险评估的研究.水利学报, 2003,34(4):40-45
    [108]Ashkar.F, Partial duration series models for flood analysis, Montreal,Canada. Ecole Polytechnique of Montreal,1980
    [109]Correia.F.N, Multivariate partial duration series in flood risk analysis. In: Singh, V.P. Hydrologic Frequency Modelling, Reidel: Dordrecht, 1987:541–554
    [110]Sackl.B, Bergmann.H, A bivariate flood model and its application. In: Singh, V.P. Hydrologic Frequency Modelling, Reidel: Dordrecht, 1987:571–582
    [111]Goel.N.K., Seth.S.M., Chandra.S, Multivariate modeling of flood flows. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 1998.124 (2):146–155.
    [112]Jain.D., Singh.V.P, A comparison of transformation methods for flood frequency analysis, Water Resource Bulletin 1986.22 (6):903–912.
    [113]Gumbel.E.J, Multivariate extreme distributions. Bulletin of the International Statistical Institute,1960. 39 (2):471–475.
    [114]S.Yue, T.B.M.J.Ouarda, B. Bobee. The Gumbel mixed model for flood frequency analysis, Journal of Hydrology, 1999. 226: 88–100
    [115]Oliveria.J.T.D. Bivariate extremes: extensions. Bulletin of the International Statistical Institute, 1975.46 : 241–251.
    [116]高木生主编,斋藤嘉博.可靠性基础数学.北京:国防工业出版社,1997
    [117]王光远,谭东耀工程系统最优可靠度的决策,工程力学1990,7(2):18-26

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700