用户名: 密码: 验证码:
世界航运网络的结构特性及其动力学行为研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
世界海洋运输系统是典型的复杂系统,它是由数百个港口和数以千计的船舶组成的,而且这些港口和船舶的数量是随时间演化的,在空间上,船舶与港口之间的联系也是千差万别的,因此对其进行整体性研究存在许多的困难,现今的研究方法仍然采用还原论的思想,将其分成子系统进行研究,虽然也得到了一些有益的成果,但是缺失了许多系统整体的信息。网络是对现实系统的一种数学抽象,它描述了系统元素之间相互作用的关系,是一种用整体论的思想来研究系统的有效工具,正因为如此,本文从复杂网络的视角,将世界海洋运输系统中的每个港口看作网络中的节点,将港口与港口之间通过船舶进行货物转移的相互联系看作网络中节点与节点之间边的连接关系,把世界海洋运输系统抽象为一种复杂网络拓扑图——世界航运网络图,这种图直观地体现了世界海洋运输系统中各个港口之间复杂的关联关系。
     本文以世界海洋运输系统为研究对象,从复杂网络的视角,利用统计分析与比较分析相结合、定性分析与定量分析相结合的方法对其进行了深入的研究,遵循着从世界航运网络的构建到网络结构统计属性的实证分析,再到寻找形成这种网络结构的机理,最后研究这种网络结构会出现什么样的动力学行为的思路开展研究工作。
     具体而言,本文在以下几个方面对世界航运网络进行了研究:
     1)根据连续的观察、调研以及对航运系统充分了解的基础上,构建了一个世界航运网络图,该图具有加权、有向和包含空间维度等特性。随后从无权和加权两个方面对网络的结构特性进行了系统的研究,得到了一系列测度参量的分布特征,比如,度、强度分布、网络特征谱表现出无标度特性;网络的平均路径长度很小以及网络簇系数却很大等特性,也就是说世界航运网络同样是一个小世界网络。除此之外,还对网络测度参数之间的相关性进行了研究,结果表明网络同时具有加权网络特性和空间网络特性,这些特性是许多其它复杂网络不曾具有的。
     2)系统的结构决定了系统的功能和行为,那么为什么世界航运网络会呈现这样的结构特性呢?这也就成为了本文需要解决的首要问题,本文作者根据长期调研世界海洋运输系统运行演化规律的结果,并结合前面统计分析得到的世界航运网络的一些结构参量分布特性,对世界航运网络的演化机理进行了深入的研究,建立了交通流驱动的世界航运网络模型和空间距离限制的世界航运网络模型,这些模型能够很好地再现世界航运网络的某些结构特性。
     3)社团结构虽然是一个社会学中的概念,但是它同系统中的传播动力学有着密切的联系,因此也是人们关注的焦点。世界航运网络中的社团结构同样值得我们的关注,因为我们可以从中发现世界各个国家之间的贸易往来联系紧密程度以及网络中交通流的分布情况,因此本文还对世界航运网络中社团结构的定义、划分标准以及划分具体的算法进行了系统的研究,得到了最优的社团个数,同时还解释了为什么在世界航运网络中会出现这样的结构划分。
     4)世界航运网络是典型的基础设施系统网络,它的效率和安全性一直是人们关注的焦点,特别是当系统受到一些意外的因素(比如像战争、恐怖袭击以及极限自然环境的干扰)影响时,系统是否依然能够表现出稳健性。另一方面系统的动力学行为必然能够反映出系统结构特性,因此最后本文还对世界航运网络的动力学行为进行了研究——鲁棒性研究,以此来验证我们所得到的系统结构特性是否准确。
     通过对世界航运网络的结构特性以及动力学行为的研究,我们可以宏观地了解各个国家之间的贸易联系,为分析各种地区间经济联系提供佐证;可以为建立新航线、合理分布航线、提高网络效率提供理论参考;可以为今后港口建设规划提供理论支持。
The global maritime shipping system is a typical complex system,it is composed by hundreds ports and thousands ships,the quantities of ports and ships are evolving with time,the relationships among them differ largely in spatial,so there exist many difficulties in researching this system in holism.Nowadays the methodology of exploring global shipping system still adopting reductive ideology,partitioning it to some subsystems for researching,some useful results have been concluded,but these results lose some integral information of system.Network is a mathematical abstract to real system,it characterizing the interactions among system elements,so it is a very useful holistic approach for researching complex system.Based on it,this dissertation regards the ports as nodes and regards the cargo flow among ports as interactive edges from complex network view,so the global maritime shipping system is characterized by a complex network topology graph-global shipping network,this graph directly embodies the complex interactions among ports of global maritime shipping system.
     In this dissertation,the global maritime shipping system is studied using complex network theory,combining the statistical with comparative analysis methods,quantitative with qualitative analysis methods.The research work was carried out following the route from constructing global shipping network to analyzing structure properties,then exploring the evolving mechanism of this particular structure,finally,discussing whatever dynamical behavior emerged from this network structure.
     Specifically,this dissertation exploring global shipping network from these aspects:
     1)Based on consecutive observation and investigation,this dissertation constructs a directed and weighted global shipping network which embedded in a spatial lattice.Then we study a set of measurements of unweighted and weighted global shipping network and attain distributing properties of some typical parameters,for example,we find the average path length of this network is so small but the cluster coefficient is very large,the degree and strength distribution following power-law.Moreover we also explore the correlation between these measurement,the results indicate that the global shipping network containing weighted as well as spatial property.
     2)The structure of system determines the function and behavior of system,the next question is why the global shipping network presents such structure? Combining the long-term investigating the evolution laws of global maritime shipping system with the statistical results attained from above,we research the evolving mechanism of the global shipping network in detail,construct a traffic driven network model and a geographical constraints network model,all the two model can reproduce some structure properties of global shipping network.
     3)Community is a conception using in sociology,meanwhile it associating with spread dynamics of system,so it becomes a hot topic.We can find the closeness trading between different countries and traffic distribution among network throng communities, we give the specific definition and partition criteria of community in global shipping network,moreover we introduce a concrete algorithm to find community in global shipping network,and obtain the best partition,at the same time,we shed light on the reasons leading to this partition.
     4)The global shipping network is a typical infrastructure network,people give much attention to its efficiency and safety,especially,focus on robustness of system when encountered accidental events(such as war,terrorist attack and perturbation of atrocious environment).On the other hand,the dynamical behavior of system must reflect the structure of system,so the last part of dissertation discusses the dynamical behavior of global shipping network,using it we can validate the accuracy of system structure obtained from our results.
     Through exploring the structure properties and dynamical behavior of global shipping network,we can understand the trading relationship among different countries macroscopically and provide proofs of analyzing local economic relations.Secondly,we can provide theoretical consult for constructing new line,distributing line fairly, improving system efficiency.Thirdly,we can provide theoretical support of designing new port.
引文
1.中华人民共和国国家统计局,2007年国民经济和社会发展统计公报,2008
    2.中华航运网,2009-2012年中国海运行业投资分析及前景预测报告,2008
    3.张嗣瀛.复杂性科学,整体规律与定性研究,复杂系统与复杂性科学,2005,2(1):71-83
    4.张嗣瀛.复杂网络的演化过程,n(n-1)律,自聚集,复杂系统与复杂性科学,2005,2(3):84-90
    5.(美)冯.贝塔朗菲.一般系统论:基础、发展和应用,林康义、魏宏森译,清华大学出版社,1987
    6.Waldrop M.Complexity-The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos,陈玲译,三联出版社,1997
    7.普朗克.世界物理图景的统一性,转引自:许国志.系统科学,上海科技出版社,2000
    8.Notteboom T.E.Container shipping and port s:an overview.Review of Network Economics,2004,3(2):86-106
    9.舒洪峰,集装箱港口发展动态研究,中国社会科学院博士论文,2007
    10.Watts D.J,Strogatz S.H.Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks.Nature,1998,393(6684):440-442
    11.Barabási A.L,Albert R.Emergence of scaling in random networks.Science,1999,286(5439):509-512
    12.Hoyle B.S,Pinder D.Cityport industrialization and regional development,Pergamon press,1981
    13.陈贻龙,邵振一,《运输经济学》,人民交通出版社,1999
    14.James B.Seaport and Seaports terminals.London:Hutchinson & co Ltd.,1971
    15.Mayer H.M.Current trend in Great Lakes shipping.Geo Journal,1978,(2):117-122
    16.Hayuth Y.Rationalization and concentration of the U.S.container port system.The professional Geographer,1988,40(3):279-288
    17.Baird A.J.Rejoinder:extending the lifecycle of container main ports in upstream urban locations,Maritime Policy & Management,1997,24:299-301
    18.曹有挥,曹卫东,中国沿海集装箱港口体系形成演化机理.地理学报,2003,58(3):424-432
    19.Erd(o|¨)s P,Rényi A.On the evolution of random graphs.Publ.Math.Inst.Hung.Acad.Sci.,1960,5,17-60
    20.Granovetter M.The strength of weak ties.American Journal of Sociology,1973,78(6):1360-1380
    21.Watts D.J,Strogatz S.H.Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks.Nature,1998,393(6684):440-442
    22.Barábasi A.L,Albert R.Emergence of scaling in random networks.Science,1999,286(5439):509-512
    23.Dorogovtsev S.N,Mendes J.F.F.Evolution of networks:from biological nets to the internet and WWW,OXFORD 2003
    24.Boccaletti S,Latra V,Moreno Y,Chavez M,D.U Hwang.Complex networks:structure and dynamics,Physics Reports,2006,424(4-5):175-308
    25.Albert R,Barabasi A.L.Statistical Mechanics of Complex Networks,cond-mat/0106096
    26.Barabasi A.L.The New Science of Networks.Massachusetts:Persus Publishing,2002
    27.Watts D.J.The 'new' science of networks.Annual Review of Sociology,2004,30:243-270
    28.汪小帆,李翔,陈关荣,复杂网络理论及其应,清华大学出版社,2006
    29.Bertalanffy V.General system Theory,转引自:许国志,系统科学,上海科技出版社,2000
    30.Erd(o¨)s P,Rényi A.On the evolution of random graphs.Publ.Math.Inst.Hung.Acad.Sci.,1960,5:17-60
    31.Bollobás B.Random Graphs.Academic Press,London,1985
    32.West D.B.Introduction to Graph Theory,Prentice-Hall,Englewood Cliffs,N.J,1995
    33.Jeong H,Mason S,et al.Lethality and centrality in protein networks.Nature,2001,411:41 -42
    34.Bogu(?)á M,Pastor-Satorras R.Epidemic spreading in correlated complex networks.Phys Rev E,2002,66:047104
    35.Vazquez A,Pastor-Satorras R.,Vespignani A.Large-scale topological and dynamical properties of the Internet.Phys Rev E,2002,65,066130.
    36.Newman M.E.J.Assortative mixing in networks.Phys Rev Lett,2002,89:208701
    37.Watts D.J.Small Worlds:The Dynamics of Networks between Order and Randomness.Princeton University Press,Princeton,NJ,1999
    38.Ahuja R.K.,Magnati T.L.,Orlin J.B.,Network Flows:Theory,Algorithms,and Applications,Prentice-Hall,Englewood Cliffs,NJ,1993.
    39.Ravasz E,Barabasi A L.Hierarchical organization in complex networks.Phys Rev E,2003,67:026112
    40.B.Hu,X.Y.Jiang,J.F.Ding,Y.B.Xie,B.H.Wang,arXiv:cond-mat/0408125
    41.Barrat A,Barthélemy M,Pastor-Satorras R,Vespignani A.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA 101,2004,3747
    42.Almaas E,Kovacs B,Vicsek T,et al.Global organization of metabolic fluxes in the bacterium Escherichia coli.Nature,2004,427:839-843
    43.Barthélemy M,Gondran B,Guichard E.Spatial structure of internet traffic.Physica A,2003,319:633
    44.Floyd R.W.Algorithm 97:shortest path,comm..ACM,1962,5:345
    45.Saram(a|¨)ki J,et al.Generalizations of the clustering coefficient to weighted complex networks Phys Rev E 75,2007,76:027105
    46.Bollobás B,Riordan O.M.Mathematical Results on scale-free Random Graphs,Handbook of graphs and networks:from the genome to the internet,2003
    47.Xulvi-Brunet R,Sokolov I.M.Evolving networks with disadvantage long-range connections.Phys Rev E,2002,66:026118
    48.Mukherjee G,Manna S.S.Growing spatial scale-free graphs by selecting local edges,arXiv:cond-mat/0503697,2005
    49.Jost J,Joy M.P.Evolving networks with distance preferences,Phys Rev E,2002,66:036126
    50.Barthelemy M.Crossover from scale-free to spatial networks,Europhys.Lett.,63(6),915-921,2003
    51.Avraham D,Rozenfeld A.F,Cohen R,Havlin S.Geographical embedding of scale-free networks,Phys A,330,107-116,2003
    52.Warren C.P,Sander L.M,Sokolov I.M.Geography in a scale-free network model,Phys Rev E,2002,66:056105
    53.Doye J.P.K,Massen C.P.Self-similar disk packings as model spatial scale-free networks,Phys Rev E,2005,71:016128
    54.Gastner M.T,Newman M.E.J.The spatial structure of networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0407680,2004.
    55.Yook S.H,Jeong H,Barabasi A.L,Y Tu.Weighted evolving networks,Phys Rev Lett,2001,86:5835-5838
    56.D Zheng,Trimper S,B Zheng,et al.Weighted scale-free networks with stochastic weight assignments.Phys Rev E,2003,67:040102.
    57.Barrat A,Barthelemy M,Vespignani A.Weighted evolving networks:Coupling topology and weighted dynamics,Phys Rev Lett,2004,92:228701
    58.Barrat A,Barthelemy M,Pastor-Satorras R,Vespignani A.The architecture of complex weighted networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0311416,2003
    59.W.X.Wang,B Hu,B.H Wang,et al.General dynamics of topology and traffic on weighted technological networks,Phys Rev Lett,2005,94:188702
    60.W.X Wang,B Hu,B.H Wang,et al.Mutual attraction model for both assortative and disassortative weighted networks,Phys Rev E,2006,73:016133
    61.Albert R,Barabasi A.L.Statistical Mechanics of Complex Networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0106096
    62.Strogatz S.H.Exploring complex networks,Nature,2001,410:268-276
    63.Costa L.F,Rodrigues A,et al.Characterization of complex networks:A survey of measurements,Adv in Phys,2007,56(1):167-242
    64.郭雷,许晓鸣,史定华等,《复杂网络》,上海科技教育出版社,2006
    65.Newman M.E.J.The structure and function of complex networks,SIAM Rev.2003,45:167-256
    66.陈关荣,复杂网络及其新近研究进展简介,力学进展,2008,38:653-662
    67.Luciano da Fontoura et al.Analyzing and Modeling Real-World Phenomena with Complex Networks:A Survey of Applications arxiv:0711.3199v1
    68.UNCTAD(联合国贸易和发展会议)2007年度统计报告,http://www.unctad.org
    69.AXS-Alphaliner Top 100:Operated fleets,http://wwwl.axsmarine.com
    70.Newman M.E.J.The structure and function of complex networks,SIAM Rev.2003,45:167-256
    71.Newman M.E.J.Power law,pareto distributions and Zipf s law.Contemporary physics,2005,46(5):323-351
    72.Dorogovtsev S.N,Mendes J.F.F,Samukin A.N.Size-dependent degree distribution of a scale-free growing networks,Phys Rev E,2001,63:062101
    73.Watts D.J.Small Worlds:The Dynamics of Networks between Order and Randomness.Princeton University Press,Princeton,NJ,1999
    74.Albert R,Jeong H,Barabasi A.L.Diameter of the world-wide web,Nature 401 1999,130-131.
    75.Freeman L.C.Centrality in social networks:conceptual clarification.Social Networks,1979(1),215-239
    76.Freeman C.L.A set of measures of centrality based on betweenness.Sociometry,1977,40:35-41
    77.Newman M.E.J,Girvan M.Finding and evaluating community structure in networks.Phys Rev E,2004,69:026113.
    78.Goh K.I,Kahng B,Kim D.Universal behavior of load distribution in scale-free networks,Phys Rev Lett,2001,87:278701
    79.Goh K.I,Oh E.S,Jeong H,Kahng B,Kim D.Classification of scale free networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0205232
    80.Berthlemy M.Betweenness centrality in large complex networks.arXiv:cond-mat/0309436
    81.Aguiar M.A.M,Bar-Yam Y.Spectral analysis and the dynamic response of complex networks.Phys Rev E,2005,71:016106.
    82.Patrick N.Graw M,Menzinger M.Laplacian Spectra as a Diagnostic Tool for Network Structure and Dynamics.arXiv:0708.4206v1
    83.Nicola P,Fortunato S.Spectral centrality measures in complex networks,Phys Rev E 2008,78:036107
    84.Dorogovtsev S.N,Goltsev A.V,Mendes J.F.E,et al.Spectra of complex networks.Phys Rev E,2003,68:046109.
    85.Rodgers G.J,Austin K,Kahng B,Kim D.Eigenvalue spectra of complex networks.Phys A,2005,38:9431-9437
    86.Goh K.I,Kahng B,Kim D.Spectra and eigenvectors of scale-free networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0103337
    87.熊文海,高齐圣,张嗣瀛,复杂网络的邻接矩阵及其特征谱,武汉理工大学学报(交通科技与工程版),2009,33(1):83-86
    88.赵永毅,史定华,复杂网络的特征谱及其应用,复杂系统与复杂性科学,2006,3(1):1-12
    89.Barrat A,Barthelemy M,Pastor-Satorras R,Vespignani A.The architecture of complex weighted networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0311416
    90.Almaas E,Kovacs B,Vicsek T,et al.Global organization of metabolic fluxes in the bacterium Escherichiacoli.Nature,2004,427:839-843
    91.Barthelemy M.,Gondran B.,Guichard E.Spatial structure of internet traffic.Physica A,2003,319:633
    92.Newman M.E.J.Assortative mixing in networks.Phys Rev Lett,2002,89:208701
    93.W.X Wang,B Hu,B.H Wang,et al.General dynamics of topology and traffic on weighted technological networks,Phys Rev Lett,2005,94:188702
    94.Ravasz E,Barabasi A.L.Hierarchical organization in complex networks.Phys Rev E,2003,67:026112
    95.T Zhou,G Yan,B.H Wang.Maximal Planar networks with large clustering coefficient and Power- law degree distribution.Phys Rev E,2005,71:04614
    96.T Zhou,B.H Wang,et al.Topological properties of integer networks,Physica A,2006,367:613-618
    97.Holme P,Kim B.J.Vertex overload breakdown in evolving networks.Phys Rev E,2002,65:066109
    98.Freeman L.C,Centrality in social networks:conceptual clarification.Social Networks,1979(1),215-239
    99.Freeman C.L.A set of measures of centrality based on betweenness.Sociometry,1977,40:35-41
    100.Newman M.E.J,Girvan M.Finding and evaluating community structure in networks.Phys Rev E,2004,69:026113.
    101.Guimera R,Amaral L.A.N.Modeling the world-wide airport network,Eur.Phys.J.B 2004,38,381-385.
    102.Guimera R,Mossa S,Turtschi A,Amaral L.A.N.The world-wide air transportation network:Anomalous centrality,community structure,and cities' global roles,arXiv:cond-mat/0312535 v2
    103.Y Fan,M.H Li,P Zhang,et al,The effect of weight on community structure of networks,Physica A 378,2007,583-589
    104.Vazquez A,Pastor-Satorras,R,Vespignani A.Large-scale topological and dynamical properties of the Internet.Phys Rev E,2002,65:066130.
    105.Newman M.E.J.Assortative mixing in networks.Phys Rev Lett,2002,89:208701
    106.Luciano da Fontoura et al.Analyzing and Modeling Real-World Phenomena with Complex Networks:A Survey of Applications.arxiv:0711.3199v1
    107.熊文海,张嗣瀛,方爱丽,加权演化的港口网络模型的研究,数学的实践与认识,2008,38(2),64-69
    108.Barabasi A.L,Albert R.Emergence of scaling in random networks.Science,1999,286(5439):509-512
    109.Albert R,Barabasi A.L.Statistical Mechanics of Complex Networks,cond-mat/0106096
    110.D Zheng,Trimper S,B Zheng,P.M Hui.Weighted scale-free networks with stochastic weight assignments,Phys Rev E,2003,67:040102
    111.Boccaletti S,Latra V,Moreno Y,Chavez M,Hwang D.U.Complex networks:structure and dynamics,Physics Reports,2006,424(4-5):175-308
    112.Gastner M.T,Newman M.E.J.The spatial structure of networks,arXiv:cond-mat/0407680,2004
    113.Jost J,Joy M.P.Evolving networks with distance preferences,Phys Rev E,2002,66:036126
    114.Barthelemy M.Crossover from scale-free to spatial networks,Europhys.Lett.,63,(6),915-921,2003.
    115.Xulvi-Brunet R,Sokolov I.M.Evolving networks with disadvantaged long-range connections,Phys Rev E,2002,66:026118
    116.Yook S.H,Jeong H,Barabasi A.L.Modeling the Internet's large-scale topology.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99,13382-13386,2002
    117.Sen P,Dasgupta S,Chatterjee A,et al.Small-world properties of the Indian railway network.Phys Rev E,2003,67:036106
    118.Watts D.J,Strogatz S.H.Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks.Nature,1998,393(6684):440-442
    119.Mark W,Homer M,OKelly E.Journal of Transport Geography,255-265,2001
    120.W.H Xiong,S.Y Zhang,Q.H Gao.Weighted Evolving Network with Geographical Constraints,2008 Chinese Control and Decision Conference,2008
    121.W.X Wang,et al.General Dynamics of Topology and Traffic on Weighted Technological Networks,Phys Rev Lett,2005,94:188702
    122.Wasserman S,Faust K.Social Networks Analysis.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1994
    123.Girvan M,Newman M.EJ.Community structure in social and biological networks Proceedings of National Academy of Science,2002,99:7821-7826.
    124.Duch J,Arenas A.Community detection in complex networks using external optimization.Phys.Rev.E,2005,72:027104
    125.Newman M.EJ.Detecting community structure in networks.Eur.Phys.J.B,2004 38:321-330.
    126.Radicchi F,Castellano C,Cecconi F,Loreto V.Defining and identifying communities in networks.Parisi,Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,2004,101(9):2658-2663
    127.Palla G,Dernyi I,Farkas I,et al.Uncovering the overlapping community structure of complex networks in nature and society.Nature,2005,435(7043):814-818
    128.Newman M.E.J,Girvan M.Finding and evaluating community structure in networks.Phys Rev E,2004,69:026113
    129.Aaron C,Newman,M.E.J,Cristopher M.Finding community structure in very large networks.Phys Rev E,2004,70:066111
    130.Newman M.E.J.Analysis of weighted networks.Phys Rev E,2004,70:056131
    131.S.H Zhang,R.S Wang,X.S Zhang.Uncovering fuzzy community structure in complex networks,Phys Rev E,2007,76:046103
    132.Kernighan B.W,Lin S.An efficient heuristic procedure for partitioning graphs.Bell System Technical Journal,1970,49:291-307
    133.Pothen A,Simon H,Liou K.P.Partitioning sparse matrices with eigenvectors of graphs.SI AM J.Matrix Anal.Appl,1990,11:430
    134.Scott J.Social Network Analysis:A Handbook,2nd ed.London:Sage Publications,2000
    135.Breiger R.L,Boorman S.A,Arable P.An algorithm for clustering relations data with applications to social network analysis and comparison with multidimensional scaling.Journal of Mathematical Psychology,1975,12:328-383
    136.Girvan M,Newman M.EJ.Community structure in social and biological networks.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.,2001,99:7821-7826
    137.Capocci A.,Servedio V.D.P,Caldarelli G,Colaiori F.Detecting communities in large networks.Physica A,2005,352(2-4):669-676
    138.S.H Zhang,R.S Wang,X.S Zhang.Identification of overlapping community structure in complex networks using fuzzy c means clustering.Physica A,2007,374(1):483-490
    139.Albert R,Jeong H,Barabasi A.L.Error and attack tolerance of complex networks.Nature,2000,406:378-382.
    140.Cohen R,Avraham D,Havlin S.Percolation critical exponents in scale-free networks,Phys Rev E,2002,66:036113
    141.Cohen R,Avraham D,Havlin S.Resilience of the internet to random breakdowns,Phys Rev Lett,2000,85:4626-4628
    142.Cohen R,Avraham D,Havlin S.Breakdown of the internet under intentional attack,Phys Rev Lett,2001,86:3682-3685
    143.Carlson J,Doyle J.Complexity and Robustness,PNAS,2002,99(Suppl.l):2539-2545
    144.Schwartz N,Cohen R,Avraham D,Barabasi A.L,Havlin S.Percolation in directed scale-free networks,Phys Rev E,2002,66:015104
    145.Cohen R,Havlin S,Avraham D.Structural Properties of Scale-Free Networks,WILEY-VCH Verlag Berlin GmbH,January 2003
    146.Kalisky T,Cohen R.Width of percolation transition in complex networks,Phys Rev E,2006,73:035101
    147.Moreno Y,Gomez J.B,Pacheco A.F.Instability of scale-free networks under node-breaking avalanches,Europhys Lett,2002,85(4):630-636
    148.Crucitti P,Latora V,Marchiori M.Model for cascading failure in complex networks,Phys Rev.E,2004,69:025103(R)
    149.Ahuja R.K,Magnati T.L,Orlin J.B.Network Flows:Theory,Algorithms,and Applications,Prentice-Hall,Englewood Cliffs,NJ,1993.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700