“海归”博导比“本土”博导的博士生指导水平更胜一筹吗?——基于中国博士毕业生调查数据的分析

详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |

英文篇名：Does Supervisor with an Overseas Doctoral Degree Perform Better than Supervisor with a Domestic Doctoral Degree on Tutoring Doctoral Students?——An Analysis Based on the National Doctoral Students Investigation 作者：李澄锋 ; 沈文钦 ; 陈洪捷 英文作者：LI Cheng-feng;SHEN Wen-qin;CHEN Hong-jie;Graduate School of Education, Peking University; 关键词：博导海外学位背景 ; 博士生学位论文指导满意度 ; 博士生国际期刊论文产出 英文关键词：supervisor with overseas doctoral degree;;satisfaction of dissertation tutoring;;output of international journal publication 中文刊名：QHDJ 英文刊名：Tsinghua Journal of Education 机构：北京大学教育学院; 出版日期：2019-04-20 出版单位：清华大学教育研究 年：2019 期：v.40;No.168 基金：2017年度教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目“博士研究生教育体制机制改革”(17JZD057);; 2016年自然科学基金面上项目“博士生学术社会化过程研究”(71673005) 语种：中文; 页：QHDJ201902015 页数：7 CN：02 ISSN：11-1610/G4 分类号：131-137

摘要

伴随着政府和高校一系列"引智"工程,高校具有海外学位背景的博导规模在迅速扩张。那么,具有海外学位背景的博导相较于"本土"博导,二者指导博士生的水平谁更胜一筹呢?本文基于2017年"中国博士毕业生调查课题"的8207份博士生数据,运用线性回归和标准负二项回归分析了博导海外学位背景对博士生学位论文指导满意度以及博士生国际期刊论产出的影响。结果显示,具有海外学位背景的博导所指导的博士生,其国际期刊论文产出更高,但学位论文指导满意度更低。
        With a series of "talent inviting project" initiated by Chinese government and universities, the scale of supervisors with overseas doctoral degrees in the universities becomes larger and larger. In this case, does supervisor with an overseas doctoral degree perform better than supervisor with a domestic doctoral degree on tutoring doctoral students? This paper focuses on the influence of supervisor with overseas doctoral degree on the satisfaction of dissertation tutoring perceived by doctoral candidates and the output of papers published on the international journal by doctoral students. We conduct an empirical research and use the Ordinary Least Regression and Negative Binomial Regression to analyze data from 61 universities and 8207 doctoral candidates participating in the National Doctoral Candidates Investigation. The results show that: supervisors with overseas doctoral degrees have a negative impact on doctoral students' satisfaction on dissertation tutoring, though they have a positive influence on the output of international journal publications of doctoral students.

引文

(1)张伟,陈英霞.我国经济学学科国际发文状况与海外博士学位教师表现分析——以北京大学、清华大学为重点的案例研究[J].清华大学教育研究,2010,(2):103-108.
    (2)余广源,范子英.“海归”教师与中国经济学科的“双一流”建设[J].财经研究,2017,(6):52-65.
    (3)李艳,马陆亭.博士生培养质量与导师相关性的实证研究[J].国家教育行政学院学报,2015,(4):78-84.
    (4)张伟,陈英霞.我国经济学学科国际发文状况与海外博士学位教师表现分析——以北京大学、清华大学为重点的案例研究[J].清华大学教育研究,2010,(2):103-108.
    (5)田美.中国青年学者英文学术论文写作与发表经历的个案研究[J].中国人民大学教育学刊,2013,(1):135-147.
    (6)Jonkers Koen and Robert Tijssen,“Chinese Researchers Returning Home:Impacts of International Mobility on Research Collaboration and Scientific Productivity,”Scientometrics 77,no.2(2008):309-333.
    (7)陈强.高级计量经济学及Stata应用[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2010.213-214.