管制放松后的企业竞争行动、竞争对手分类与销售绩效

详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |

英文篇名：Firm Competitive Action, the Category of Rivals and Sales Performance after Deregulation 作者：袁靖波 ; 周志民 ; 周南 ; 周晨 英文作者：Yuan Jingbo; 关键词：竞争行动 ; 竞争对手 ; 组内竞争 ; 组间竞争 ; 销售绩效 ; 管制放松 中文刊名：GLSJ 英文刊名：Management World 机构：深圳大学管理学院;南卡罗莱纳大学达拉穆尔商学院; 出版日期：2019-06-15 出版单位：管理世界 年：2019 期：v.35 基金：国家自然科学基金项目(批准号:71702110、71832010);; 中国博士后科学基金项目(批准号:2017M610550、2018T110893);; 广东省普通高校省级重大项目(批准号:2016WZDXM006)的资助 语种：中文; 页：GLSJ201906015 页数：15 CN：06 ISSN：11-1235/F 分类号：185-198+202

摘要

基于亚洲14个国家(地区)电信企业的二手数据,本文检验了企业竞争行动与销售绩效之间的主效应,以及组内竞争和组间竞争对上述主效应的调节作用。研究发现,企业竞争行动密集性、异质性与销售绩效正相关,企业竞争行动简单性与销售绩效负相关;市场竞争(包括组内竞争与组间竞争)对企业竞争行动密集性、异质性与销售绩效之间的关系存在负向调节,对企业竞争行动简单性与销售绩效之间关系存在正向调节。从3个战略群组的对比看,在企业成员规模越小的战略群组中,组内竞争对企业竞争行动与销售绩效之间关系的调节效应越强;在企业成员规模越大的战略群组中,组间竞争对企业竞争行动与销售绩效之间关系的调节效应越强。上述结论表明,组内竞争对小企业最为不利,组间竞争对大企业最为不利。
        Based on the second-hand data of the telecom firms in 14 Asian countries, we examined the main effects between competitive action and sales performance, as well as the moderate effect of Within-group rivalry and Betweengroup rivalry on the main effects. The results show that the intensity/heterogeneity of firm's competitive action is positively related to sales performance, but the simplicity of firm's competitive action is negative related to sales performance; Market rivalry(include Within-group Rivalry and Between-group Rivalry) has a significantly negative moderate effect on the relationship between the intensity/heterogeneity and sales performance; However, it has a significantly positive moderate effect on the relationship between the simplicity and sales performance. From the comparison of the three strategy groups, with the decrease in the size of firm members that constitute a strategic group, the moderate effect of Within-group Rivalry on the relationship between firm's competitive action and sales performance is increase.On the contrary, with the increase in the size of firm members that constitute a strategic group, the moderate effect of Between-group Rivalry on the relationship between firm's competitive action and sales performance is increase. The research findings show that: Within-group Rivalry has a more negative effect on small firms, Between-group Rivalry has a more negative effect on large firms.

引文

(1)Afshartous,D.and R.A.Preston,2010,“Confidence Intervals for Dependent Data:Equating Non-overlap with Statistical Significance”,Computational Statistics&Data Analysis,Vol.54(10),pp.2296~2305.
    (2)Ahmet,H.K.,S.Jayachandran.and W.O.Bearden,2005,“Market Orientation:A Meta-Analytic Review and Assessment of Its Antecedents and Impact on Performance”,Journal of Marketing,Vol.69(4),pp.24~41.
    (3)Baum,J.C.,R.Cowan.and N.Jonard,2014,“Does Evidence of Network Effects on Firm Performance in Pooled Cross-Section Support Prescriptions for Network Strategy?”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.35(5),pp.652~667.
    (4)Belia,S.,F.Fidler,J.Williams and G.Cumming,2005,“Researchers Misunderstand Confidence Intervals and Standard Error Bars”,Psychological Methods,Vol.10(4),pp.389~396.
    (5)Connelly,B.L.,L.Tihanyi,D.J.Ketchen Jr.,C.Matz Carnes and W.J.Ferrier,2017,“Competitive Repertoire Complexity:Governance Antecedents and Performance Outcomes”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.38(5),pp.1151~1173.
    (6)Cattani,G.,J.Porac and H.Thomas,2017,“Categories and Competition”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.38(1),pp.64~92.
    (7)Chen,M.J.and D.Miller,2012,“Competitive Dynamics:Themes,Trends,and a Prospective Research Platform”,The Academy of Management Annals,Vol.6(1),pp.135~210.
    (8)Chen,M.J.and D.Hambrick,1995,“Speed,Stealth,and Selective Attack:How Small Firms Differ from Large Firms in Competitive Behavior”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.38(2),pp.453~482.
    (9)Cool,K.and I.Dierickx,1993,“Rivalry,Strategic Groups and Firm Profitability”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.14(1),pp.47~59.
    (10)Dranove,D.,M.Peteraf.and M.Shanley,1998,“Do Strategic Groups Exist?An Economic Framework for Analysis”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.19(11),pp.1029~1044.
    (11)D’Aveni,R.,1994,Hyper-Competition:Managing the Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering,New York:Freedom Press.
    (12)Evgeniou,T.,L.Fang,R.M.Hogarth.and N.Karelaia,2013,“Competitive Dynamics in Forecasting:The Interaction of Skill and Uncertainty”,Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,Vol.26(4),pp.375~384.
    (13)Evanoff,D.,D.and E.Ors,2008,“The Competitive Dynamics of Geographic Deregulation in Banking:Implications for Productive Efficiency”,Journal of Money Credit&Banking,Vol.40(5),pp.897~928.
    (14)Funk,R.J.and D.Hirschman,2014,“Derivatives and Deregulation:Financial Innovation and the Demise of Glass-Steagall”,Administrative Science Quarterly,Vol.59(4),pp.669~704.
    (15)Ferrier,W.and D.Lyon,2004,“Competitive Repertoire Simplicity and Firm Performance:the Moderating Role of Top Management Team Heterogeneity”,Managerial and Decision Economics,Vol.25(6),pp.317~327.
    (16)Ferrier,W.,K.Smith and C.Grimm,1999,“The Role of Competitive Action in Market Share Erosion and Industry Dethronement:A Study of Industry Leaders and Challengers”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.42(4),pp.372~388.
    (17)Gomez,J.,R.Orcos and S.Palomas,2014,“The Evolving Patterns of Competition after Deregulation:the Relevance of Institutional and Operational Factors as Determinants of Rivalry”,Journal of Evolutionary Economics,Vol.24(4),pp.905~933.
    (18)Giachetti,C.and G.B.Dagnino,2014,“Detecting the Relationship between Competitive Intensity and Firm Product Line Length:Evidence from the Worldwide Mobile Phone Industry”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.35(9),pp.1398~1409.
    (19)Hsieh,K.Y.and E.Hyun,2016,“Concentration of Rivals’Actions and Competitive Reactio”,Management Decision,Vol.54(9),pp.2188~2207.
    (20)Hitt,M.A.,R.E.Hoskisson and R.Duane Ireland,1990,“Mergers and Acquisitions and Managerial Commitment to Innovation in M-Form Firms”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.24(4),pp.29~47.
    (21)Jindal,R.P.,K.R.Sarangee,R.Echambadi and S.Lee,2016,“Designed to Succeed:Dimensions of Product Design and Their Impact on Market Share”,Journal of Marketing,Vol.80(4),pp.72~89.
    (22)Kilduff,G.J.,A.D.Galinsky,E.Gallo.and J.J.Reade,2016,“Whatever It Takes to Win:Rivalry Increases Unethical Behavior”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol.59(5),pp.1508~1534.
    (23)Leask,G.and D.Parker,2007,“Strategic Groups,Competitive Groups and Performance Within the U.K.Pharmaceutical Industry:Improving our Understanding of the Competitive Process”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.28(7),pp.723~745.
    (24)Morgan,M.and W.Ferrier,2014,“Competitive Action Repertoires and Stock Risk”,Journal of Managerial Issue,Vol.26(1),pp.55~69.
    (25)Mas-Ruiz,F.J.,F.Ruiz-Moreno and A.L.Guevara Martinez,2014,“Asymmetric Rivalry Within and Between Strategic Groups”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.35(3),pp.419~439.
    (26)Mas-Ruiz,F.J.and F.Ruiz-Moreno,2011,“Rivalry Within Strategic Groups and Consequences for Performance:The Firm-Size Effects”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.32(12),pp.1286~1308.
    (27)Macher,J.T.and J.W.Mayo,2010,“Making a Market out of a Mole Hill?Geographic Market Definition in Aspen Skiing”,Journal of Competition,Law&Economics,Vol.6(4),pp.911~926.
    (28)Marinova,D.,J.Ye.and J.Singh,2008,“Do Frontline Mechanisms Matter?Impact of Quality and Productivity Orientations on Unit Revenue,Efficiency and Customer Satisfaction”,Journal of Marketing,Vol.72(2),pp.28~45.
    (29)Miller,D.and M.J.Chen,1996a,“The Simplicity of Competitive Repertoires:An Empirical Analysis”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.17(1),pp.419~439.
    (30)Miller,D.and M.J.Chen,1996b,“Nonconformity in Competitive Repertoires:A Sociological View of Markets”,Social Forces,Vol.74(4),pp.1209~1234.
    (31)Ndofor,H.A.,D.G.Sirmon and X.He,2011,“Firm Resources,Competitive Actions and Performance:Investigating a Mediated Model with Evidence from the In-vitro Diagnostics Industry”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.32(6),pp.640~657.
    (32)O’Sullivan,D.and A.V.Abela,2007,“Marketing Performance Measurement Ability and Firm Performance”,Journal of Marketing,Vol.71(2),pp.73~93.
    (33)Patel,P.C.and D.Cooper,2014,“Structural Power Equality between Family and Non-family TMT Members and the Performance of Family Firms”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol.57(6),pp.1624~1649.
    (34)Prince,J.T.and D.H.Simon,2009,“Multimarket Contact and Service Quality:Evidence From On-Time Performance In the U.S.Airline Industry”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol.52(2),pp.336~354.
    (35)Park,S.H.and D.Zhou,2005,“Firm Heterogeneity and Competitive Dynamics in Alliance Formation”,Academy of Management Review,Vol.30(3),pp.531~554.
    (36)Peteraf,M.A.,1993,“The Cornerstones of Competitive Advantage:A Resource-based View”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.14(3),pp.179~191.
    (37)Rindova,V.,W.J.Ferrier and R.Wiltbank,2010,“Value From Gestalt:How Sequences of Competitive Actions Create Advantage for Firms in Nascent Markets”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.31(13),pp.1474~1497.
    (38)Ramani,G.and V.Kumar,2008,“Interaction Orientation and Firm Performance”,Journal of Marketing,Vol.72(1),pp.27~45.
    (39)Smith,K.,C.Grimm and S.Wally,1997,“Strategic Groups and Rivalrous Firm Behavior:Toward a Reconciliation”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol.18(2),pp.149~157.
    (40)Smith,K.,C.Grimm,M.Gannon and M-J.Chen,1991,“Organizational Information Processing,Competitive Responses,and Performance in the U.S.Domestic Airline”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol.34(1),pp.60~85.
    (41)Wooldridge,J.M.,2010,Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data,Cambridge:MIT Press.
    (42)YuzT.and A.A.Cannella,2007,“Rivalry between Multinational Enterprises:An Event History Approach”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol.50(3),pp.665~686.
    (43)Young,G.,K.Smith and C.Grimm,1996,“‘Austrian’and Industrial Organization Perspectives on Firm-level Competitive Activity and Performance”,Organization Science,Vol.7(3),pp.243~254.
    (44)蔡宏波、任国良:《技术差异、非对称管制与电信市场演化》,《财经研究》,2013年第4期。
    (45)邓新明、龙良智、龙贤义、叶珍:《竞争者分析与企业市场、非市场进攻行动选择的关联性研究》,《管理评论》,2017年第11期。
    (46)顾昕:《俘获、激励和公共利益:政府管制的新政治经济学》,《中国行政管理》,2016年第4期。
    (47)靳庆鲁、侯青川、李刚、谢亚茜:《放松卖空管制、公司投资决策与期权价值》,《经济研究》,2015年第10期。
    (48)皮圣雷、蓝海林:《中国横向整合企业竞争策略组合与组织协调性:转型期制度情境的调节作用》,《管理世界》,2014年第4期。
    (49)杨开忠、陶然、刘明兴:《解除管制、分权与中国经济转轨》,《中国社会科学》,2003年第3期。