我国证券市场系统性风险的度量与成因分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
我国证券市场尽管经历了十年的风雨,但是根据以往的研究成果说明其市场有效性远远不够,证券市场的价格发现功能和资金配置功能并没有得到充分发挥。从近十年的股票价格波动来看,我国证券市场上的股票基本上呈现齐涨齐落的形态,各股之间的风险差异很小。在这样的市场上,投资者趋利避险的投资意图就难以实现,即使作为机构投资者,有充足的资金和技术通过构建投资组合来规避风险,但从实际投资效果来看,投资组合的避险功能是有限的。本文的研究目的就是通过分析我国证券市场的非系统风险和系统风险的构成,得出影响投资组合效果的主要风险因素,并讨论在我国市场通过引入衍生金融工具来对冲风险的可能性和可行性。
    国外大多数成熟的理论已经证实:投资组合的分散化能够规避部分规避风险。尽管如此,事实证明在我国证券市场上有些理论是不适用的。本文从风险的度量入手,通过系统的模型分析和实证研究,在资本资产定价模型基础上进行提炼和修正,并运用近五年我国证券市场的基本资料运用CAPM基本模型进行实证研究。同时针对我国的具体情况,找出这些理论不适用的原因,提出系统风险的规避是我国不论中小投资者或是机构投资者都必须面对的问题。而已有的理论和时间都已经证明系统风险是不能通过投资组合加以分散的,那么这就需要分析我国证券市场系统风险形成的原因,对症下药,找出适当的规避方法。本文将从资本市场的流动性、入市资金结构、市场微观结构、交易品种单一的缺陷对系统风险的影响入手分析我国证券市场系统性风险形成的原因。
    近年来,我国证券市场扩容的速度不断加快,随着市场上理性的机构投资者增加,我国证券市场上原有投资品种单一的局面已经不能满足投资者的需要。由于我国目前既没有做空机制,又缺乏风险对冲工具,所以投资者要规避系统性风险只能从股市退出。因此,本文提出,做空机制的引入、衍生金融工具的创新是规避我国市场系统风险的重要手段,能帮助投资者真正实现趋利避险的投资目的。在本文最后将讨论通过引入衍生金融工具——股指期货规避市场系统性风险的可能性和可行性。股指期货作为风险管理的有效工具,既能满足投资者规避系统性风险的需要,又在一定程度上弥补了现货市场没有做空机制的缺陷。
Tough we have experienced the developing phase of ten years, we can easily find that the obvious flaws in our stock market according to the discoveries of previous research. The most important point is that our market is seriously ineffective and certain function is severely hampered. The price is incompatible with the real value of the stock, thus the function of allocating resources of the capital market cannot work normally. Researching from the fluctuation of the market,we can find the prices of all the stocks always fluctuate simultaneously, so the investors cannot elude the systematic risk effectively by selecting certain kinds of stocks or building portofolio combination. Then the goal of maximizing profits cannot realize relatively. Even if the institutional investors have enough money and experiences to constitute profitable set, they cannot still elude systematic risk. On the bases of our analysis, the research of systematic risk in our market will benefit both individual investors and institutional investors.
     Many researchers find the multiplied investment can help eliminating certain risk exposed to the investors, but the specific premiums of the theories is inapplicable in our market. In our research, we begin with the evaluation of the risk, find the related reasons of the invalidation by collecting and analyzing real data of our market. Through analysis, we conclud that the systematic risk cannot be neglected by all the investors. So we need to find the reasons of generating systematic risks in our stock market. On the basis of the original model of CAPM, we make some adjustment when evaluating the risk of our stock market, changing the situation of thinking over only one single factor of the conventional models and neglecting the impact of different periods on the fluctuation of the market.
     In the resent years, our stock market developed very soon, more and more listed companies appear in the board. Accompanied by the fast development of the market, the liquidity should be strengthened too. In a market whose liquidity and the selection of kinds of investment is limited, the investors cannot elude systematic risk effectively. So we should introduce new kind of investment tools and strengthen the variety of investment. If we introduce a certain kind of financial derivatives, investors can minimize the systematic risk they confront by the adverse operation in the derivative market. So we discuss the necessity and the applicability of introducing certain financial derivatives in the last phase of the dissertation.
引文
[1] 吴晓求.中国资本市场:未来10年.北京:中国财政经济出版社 2000
    [2] [美]约翰.霍尔.期权、期货和衍生证券.华夏出版社 1997
    [3] 杨秀苔.刘星编译.证券投资原理.重庆大学出版社 1998
    [4] 宋逢明.金融工程原理--无套利均衡分析.清华大学出版社 1999
    [5] 吴晓求等.FSI中国资本市场研究报告.中国人民大学出版社 2001
    [6] George W.Gallinger,Jerry B.Poe.Essentials of Finance: An Integrated Approach. Prentice Hall 1995
    [7] James L.Farrell,Jr. Portfolio Management: Theory and Application. McGraw-Hill 1998
    [8] 法博齐.莫迪利安尼.资本市场:机构与工具.经济科学出版社 1998
    [9] 古扎拉蒂.计量经济学(第三版)(上、下册).中国人民大学出版社 2002
    [10] 陈共,周升业,吴晓求.中国证券法规总汇.中国财政经济出版社 2000
    [11] 李启明,申力银.风险管理中的风险效应-行为决策模型及分析.经济研究.2001.10
    [12] 李伟.我国股票价格指数期货的风险分析与防范.统计与决策.2001.8
    [13] 陈彩虹.机会成本概念与金融衍生产品的功能分析.证券市场导报.2002.2
    [14] 陈共.股票指数期货的理论分析.中国经济信息.2001.16
    [15] 王长元.金融产品开发与现金流重组技术. 证券市场导报.2002.3
    [16] 员瑞恒.金融创新与金融体系稳定性.中华财会网(www.e521.com) 2002-01-21
    [17] 刘力耕. 金融衍生品市场研究.金融与保险.2002.3
    [18] 周明.谈股指期货设定及其他. 中华财会网(www.e521.com) 2002-01-21
    [19] 梁定邦.我国资本市场前瞻.中国证券报.2002.2.1
    [20] 姚兴涛.可投资性与股指创新核心分析.国际金融报 2001.12.19
    [21] 股指期货研究十大问题探讨.中国证券报.2001.10.31
    [22] 何志刚.指数套利:推出股指期货值得注意的一个问题.数量经济技术经济研究 2002.5
    [23] 吉林大学商学院数量经济研究中心.我国证券市场结构分析及优化. 数量经济技术经济研究.2002.3
    [24] 李建伟.未来金融创新新领域:资产证券化. 巨潮互联资讯
    [25] 2000年政策性因素对我国证券市场的影响及潜在政策分析. 巨潮互联资讯
    [26] 析股指现货交易.上海证券报.巨潮互联资讯
    [27] Leslie Edward. Practical Risk Management in the Construction Industry. Thomas Telford,1995.15-31
    [28] Patrick S Godfrey. Control-A Guide to the Systematic Managemnt of Risk. CIRIA,1996.28-35
    
    
    [29] David Hertz,Howard Thomas. Practical Risk Analysis: An Approach Through Case Histories,John wiley&Sons.1984
    [30] Jerry S Rosenbloom. A case Study in Risk Management.Prentice-Hall.Englewood Cliffs,1972
    [31] Jake Ansell,Frank Wharton. Risk Analysis, Assessment and Management.John Wiley& Sons,Inc.1982
    [32] Dickson GCA. Risk Analysis.Witherby&Co.Ltd,1991.1-6
    [33] John F Burchett, Rao VMTummala. The application of the risk management process in capital investment decisions for EHV transmissiouline project.Construction Management& Economics1998.16
    [34] Johnuc Chicken,Michael R Hayns. The Risk Ranking Technique in Decision Making.Pergamon Press.1989
    [35] Neil Crockford. An introduction to Risk Management. Woodhead.Faulkner, Cambridge 1986 11-12
    [36] 陈根荣 吴冲锋.金融衍生市场上企业套期保值的动机理论研究.国际金融研究2001.8
    [37] 蒋殿春 张新.可转换公司债定价问题研究.国际金融研究 2002.4
    [38] 王海燕 赵培标.金融工程内蕴研究.国际金融研究 2002.2
    [39] 杨星.股指期货合约设计的国际比较与借鉴.国际金融研究 2001.9
    [40] 秦宛顺 刘霖.中国股票市场协整现象与价格动态调整过程研究.金融研究 2001.4
    [41] 瞿强.国债流动性研究--一个比较分析框架.金融研究 2001.6
    [42] 杨朝军 蔡明超 傅继波.上海股票市场资本定价的横截面研究.系统工程理论与实践 2001.10
    [43] 陈小悦.中国股市弱型效率的实证研究.会计研究.1997. 9
    [44] 陈旭.国家股流通新路:可交换债券.中国投资.1999.12
    [45] 俞乔.市场有效、周期异常与股价波动.经济研究.1994.9
    [46] 陶正傲.强化信息披露是使证券市场达到有效市场的前提.南开经济研究1998.2
    [47] 宋颂兴、金伟根.上海股市市场有效实证研究.经济学家.1995.4
    [48] 吴世农.我国证券市场效率的分析.经济研究1996.4
    [49] 郭宝新等编著.金融期货期权及其市场监管.中国金融出版社.1999
    [50] 赵曙东著.期货投资和期权.南京大学出版社.1999
    [51] 张人骥.财务理论的分析基础.1994.
    [52] 施东辉.上海证券市场风险的国际比较.经济研究.1996.11
    [53] 刘虎.上证30样本股指数的实证分析.申银万国证券研究.1997.6
    [54] 赵锡军等译.威廉·F·夏普等著.投资学(第五版).1998.中国人民大学出版社
    [55] 陈晗等.股票指数期货--理论、经验与市场运作构想.2000.上海远东出版社
    
    
    [56] 陈小锐.姚怡.上海股市风险与收益定量分析.经济科学.1995.1
    [57] 宋颂兴.金伟根.上海股市市场有效性实证研究.经济学家.1995.4
    [58] 王安兴.林少宫.投机价格与非投机价格的发现.数量经济与技术经济研究.1998年第12期
    [59] 吴其明.季忠贤.杨晓荣.自回归条件异方差模型及应用.预测.1998.4
    [60] 丁华.股价指数波动中的ARCH现象.数量经济与技术经济研究.1999.9
    [61] Eugene F. Fama James D. Macbeth.1973.Risk,Return,Equilibrium:Empirical Tests.Journal
    of Political Economy.607—636
    [62] Eugene F. Fama.1991.Efficient Market.Journal of Finance.427—465
    [63] EugeneF.Fama.Kenneth French.1992.The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns.Journal of Finance.427—465
    [64] Richard Roll.Stephen Ross.1994.On the Cross- Sectional Relation between Expected Returns and Betas.Journal of Finance.101—121
    [65] John Y. Campbell Andrew W. LoA.Craig Mac Kinlay.1997.The Economitrics of Financial Mar-
    kets.Princeton University Press.
    [66] Alan L.Tucker Kent G. Becker Michael J. Isimbabi Joseph P. Ogden .1994.Contemporary Portfolio Thoery and Risk Management.West Publishing Company