用户名: 密码: 验证码:
中国农民工职业发展问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
世界各国现代化过程中,劳动力流动的普遍规律是由农民一步转化为市民。在中国大陆,由于户籍世袭制度使农民转化为市民过程中停留在农民工状态。每年城市化增长约1%即近1000万人进城,中国大陆大约每天会消失300个100人的村庄,从村庄里消失的人口绝大部分成了城市里的农民工。农民工对中国现代化的贡献已经得到社会的广泛承认。经过30年的努力,中国大陆农民成为农民工已经没什么障碍,下一步的核心问题是农民工市民化。
     如同农民进城成为农民工是中国农民的第三大创举,第四大创举应是农民工的职业发展。开放改革后,中国农民的第一大创举是搞联产承包制使农业部门劳动力富余,第二大创举是创办乡镇企业衰落了同类低效率的国营企业。中国现代化要解决的主要问题是三农问题,农民工问题是中国三农问题的核心。开放改革超过三十年的今天,农民工职业发展问题已经成为解决农民工问题的核心。若大部分农民工不能市民化,中国现代化不可能成功,农民工职业发展问题成为影响中国现代化进程的事关全局的大事。农民工市民化,还得靠农民工自己的再一次创举:农民工职业发展。期望中国农民工的职业发展推动市民化制度与政策逐步松动,进一步推动中国现代化。制度政策因素之外,必须也只能靠农民工自己职业发展才能跨越韧性更强的市民化隐性门槛,达成经济层面的市民化。
     研究表明:大部分农民工职业发展意愿强烈,但不懂职业发展规划,也缺乏职业发展方法。四类农民工中,职业发展主要在制造业、服务业两类,告知这两类农民工其职业发展位阶,各位阶递进所需要的知识技能、发展方法,知识精英可以通过帮助农民工职业发展为中国现代化多做出一点有益贡献。农民工工资数据分析显示,农民工职业发展四个层级之间收入差别是巨大的。通过25省市区调查数据的计量分析,农民工职业发展影响显著的因素是文化程度、职业技能训练、职业关系网络、狭义细分行业工作时间长度、雷同岗位累积工作时间长度,等等。除了二元社会结构及制度政策原因,文化程度低和针对性职业技能训练欠缺,是农民进城后职业发展追赶市民的主要障碍。农民工最初学历文化程度低已成事实,只能靠继续教育改善,然而调查显示农民工对目前社会提供的继续教育的评价是负面的。农民工职业发展,靠在职针对性的职业技能训练。运用数学和经济学一般通用基础知识发展出农民工职业技能训练的理论——农民工职业发展的经济学分析,替代一般性说教劝导,农民工更易接受和信服,更容易引导和促进农民工职业发展,这点已经得到实践证明。农民工学习靠经验感性模仿,初级农民工的模仿对象是精英农民工我们可以首先帮助部分精英农民工获得进一步职业发展急需的继续教育培训:大专知识结构和针对性职业技能训练,利用这部分精英农民工职业发展的榜样效应和传染效应,使大部分农民工达成通过职业发展实现市民化的愿望。
     研究建议:创办服务数亿农民工职业发展的中国农民工职业大学,考虑农民工低学术性重职业发展所需的针对性知识结构和针对性职业技能训练,需创造适合于农民工时间和资金有限而要求短、平、快见效的教学方式,即需要达成高效地增强农民工的人力资本。创新高等职业教育、改革广播电视大学办学模式,成为中国农民工职业大学的同盟者,共同服务于农民工职业发展。继续教育的高职大专知识结构,能够帮助农民工蛙跳式职业发展到达高级位阶。有行业经验技能的农民工再辅以大专知识结构,创业成功率高;已经创业的农民工老板补充大专知识结构,能更好地把握企业经营、提高效益。纯粹由农民工集聚而成的纯农民工企业——以珠三角服装和皮具加工小型企业为例,需要克服在研发设计、人力资源、质量和供应链这四大管理弱点,使纯农民工企业的管理提升及纯农民工企业内各层次农民工获得职业发展。纯农民工企业全部存在这四大弱点是因为这些虚的又是构成核心竞争力的系统性逻辑性管理技能无法模仿得到,需要学习运用高职大专文化知识,或者靠一个个企业教练带领一个个企业内部团队练出来,有丰富企业管理经验的知识精英应提供这方面的支持。本文创新的纯农民工企业管理提升的外部服务模型,实践中已经有好表现。
     建设知识精英直接帮助农民工的平台,创办中国农民工职业大学,都需要政府政策支持。应加大财政支持力度,加强研究并支持实践。
In almost all countries'modernization, the labor flux is from rural area to urban, more and more peasants became citizens. However, in China mainland, most peasants stay as the peasant-workers because of the "hukou" policy, although they have lived and worked in cities for many years. About1%of annual urbanization growth means every year nearly10million people transfer into cities,300villages with100people disappears every day, most of the "disappeared" villagers become peasant-workers. The peasant-workers' contribution to China modernization has been widely recognized by the whole society. After3decades struggle, no more obstacles prevent a peasant becoming a peasant-worker, the next core issue is to let peasant-workers become full citizens.Peasants pouring into city and becoming peasant-workers was the3rd great innovation created by China peasants. Peasant-worker's career developing may be the4th great innovations. Starting from open and reform, China peasant had the1st great innovation-the household contract responsibility system, which generated great amount of surplus rural labor forces. The2nd innovation is establishing township enterprises, which crushed many low-efficiency nation-own companies.
     Issues of agriculture, peasant and rural area are the key to China modernization, peasant-worker issue is the core of the key. Today,30years after the open and reform, peasant-worker career developing becomes the core of peasant worker issue. China modernization is impossible to succeed if most peasant worker failed to transfer into citizens. So peasant-worker career developing becomes one of the key issues during China modernization. Peasant-worker merging into city still relies on the peasant-workers' another innovation——peasant-worker career developing. It is an expectation that the peasant-worker career developing can push the city "hukou" policy unlock bit by bit, and push forward the China modernization. Besides government policy side, it must depend on and can only depend on career developing, only in this way the peasant-workers may stride over the cover-up threshold, to become the full citizen in economic side.
     The findings:Most peasant-workers have strong desire with career developing, however, they have no idea of career development planning, and didn't know how to achieve career development. Among four groups of peasant-workers, career developing mainly suitable to peasant-workers in manufacturing and service field. Intellectual elites can tell them career phase and train them with the knowledge and skills for further career development. In this way, the intellectual elites can provide positive contribution to China modernization. The peasant-workers payroll analysis showed:The income of peasant-workers at the four career levels varied greatly. By quantitative analyzing the survey information from25provinces in China mainland, for peasant-worker career development, the main factors are education level, occupational skills training, interpersonal network, and working years in specific industry, accumulated working years in similar position, etc. Besides dual social structure and government policy, the main obstacles that peasant-workers competitiveness lag behind original citizen are lower education and poor occupational skills training. Lower education is the fact, but the peasant-workers can change it by continuous education, it is a pity that most peasant-workers have negative impression to current continuous education system. Peasant-worker career development should focus on specific occupational skills training and on-job training. Use some general basic knowledge from mathematics and economic to develop a series of theory(Economic analysis for peasant-worker career development) for peasant-workers' occupational skills training, to replace traditional training conduction. This has been proved to be more convictive to peasant-workers, and easier to guide and promote their career development. Most peasant-workers learn by imitating or copying with perceptual experience, primary peasant-workers imitate elite peasant-workers, we can firstly arrange continuing education training to some elite peasant-workers, may include knowledge and occupational skills training that are urgently needed for their career development. Then use the successful elite peasant-workers as examples to induce and encourage the primary peasant-workers'will of urbanization via the career development. The research proposals:To establish China Peasant-worker Vocational School for millions of peasant-workers, should consider the lower education of peasant workers to provide specific both knowledge and occupational skills training, also need to consider peasant-workers can only offer limited time and limited capital. It is important to create a new teaching style that required short-time, and can achieve effects soon. We need innovate current higher vocational education and reform the education Pattern of Radio&TV university, become allies of China Peasant-worker Vocational School, to service peasant-worker career development.Getting college knowledge by continuous education can help peasant-worker realize leapfrogging-oriented carrier development. Experienced peasant-workers with college knowledge may get higher success rate for carve out; for the peasant-worker had successfully carved out, will run business more effectively after getting college knowledge by continuous education. Pure peasant-worker entrepreneur (where both the employee and boss are peasant-workers) need to conquer the four weaknesses which are Research&Development, Human Resource, Quality Assurance and Supply Chain Management——In the pearl river delta clothing and leather processing small company as an example. Only then it is possible to raise the management level of pure peasant-enterprise, and promote career developing for every level peasant-worker inside. Pure peasant-worker enterprise have such weaknesses because such knowledge are vain and peasant-worker can't copy them. But they are systematic and logic management skills that formed core competitiveness. This can be solved by peasant-worker to study and apply college knowledge, or by having enterprise coach to help training the company team respectively. Intellectual elites with rich management experience should offer such support. The author innovated "external service model" that used to improve the management of pure peasant-worker enterprise already had very good practice performance.
     Intellectual elites need government policy support to set up the institution, or establish the China peasant-worker Vocational School, so that they can help peasant-workers directly. The government should increase financial support, strengthen research and support practice.
引文
[1]胡鞍钢.中国存在“四农”问题农民工问题是核心[J].思想政治教学,2005(4):73-73
    [2]刘小年.重新认识农民工——兼论农民工认识上的4大误区[J].安徽农业科学,2006,34(15):3802-3804
    [3]崔传义.农民工问题是政治问题[J].研究与实践,2006(2):42
    [4]赵锦辉.解决农民工问题与构建和谐社会[J].中共石家庄市委党校学报,2006,8(5):22-23
    [5]杨思远.中国农民工的政治经济学考察[M].中国经济出版社,2005
    [6]周冰.有限理性与过渡性制度安排[J].天津社会科学,2001(3):52-55
    [7]韩长赋.中国农民工的发展与终结[M].中国人民大学出版社,2007
    [8]张路雄.法国骚乱事件警示中国新生代外来工问题[J].凤凰周刊,2006(33)
    [9]马春文.发展经济学[M].高等教育出版社,2000
    [10]南亮进、牧野文夫.流动的大河:中国的农村劳动力流动(流れゅ<大河中国农村労働の移动)[J].日本评论社,东京1999)
    [11]Brauw Alan de等.在改革中的中国农村劳动力市场的演变[M].社会科学文献出版社,2002
    [12]Kenneth Roberts, Female Labor Migrants to Shanghai:Temporary "Floaters" or Potential Settlers? International Migration Review,36(2):492-519, Summer 2002.
    [13]黄平,杜铭那克.农民工反贫困:城市问题与政策导向[M].中英双语本,社会科学文献出版社,2006
    [14]朱农.中国劳动力流动与“三农”问题[M].武汉大学出版社,2005
    [15]瑞雪·墨菲.农民工改变中国农村[M].浙江人民出版社,2008
    [16]魏成.中国农民工调查[M].中国法律出版社,2007
    [17]Ye Jingzhong, James Murray, WangYihuan.LEFT-BEHIND CHILDREN IN RURAL CHINA[M].社会科学文献出版社,2006
    [18]刘恒中.论中国大发展:八亿农民变市民[M].中国财政经济出版社,2008
    [19]蔡防.中国的二元经济与劳动力转移[M].中国人民大学出版社,1990
    [20]辜胜阻,简新华.当代中国人口流动与城镇化[M].武汉大学出版社,1994
    [21]王春光.社会流动与社会重构——京城“浙江村”研究[M].浙江人民出版社,1995
    [22]杜鹰.白南生.走出乡村:中国农村劳动力流动实证研究[M].经济科学出版社,1997
    [23]李强.中国大陆城市农民工的职业流动[J].社会学研究,1999(03)
    [24]李培林.农民工——中国进城农民工的经济社会分析[M].社会科学文献出版社,2003
    [25]许经勇.“三农问题”与资本原始积累[J].福建行政学院福建经济管理干部学院学报,2004(4)
    [26]程国栋.农民进城务工新动向经济学透视[J].福建论坛(人文社会科学版),2005(6)
    [27]刘光宇.经济学视角下的中国农民工非正规就业[J].甘肃农业,,2005(9)
    [28]刘玮.农民工歧视现象的经济学分析[J].甘肃农业,2005(1)
    [29]许圣道.解决好农民工问题的经济学思考[J].经济经纬,2006(2)
    [30]刘小年.中国农民工政策研究[M].湖南人民出版社,2007
    [31]同[7]
    [32]张国胜.中国农民工市民化:社会成本视角的研究[M].人民出版社,2008
    [33]熊贵彬.国家权力与社会结构视野下的农民工城市化[M].中国社会出版社,2009
    [34]郑小兰,冯海涛.构建新生代农民工职业教育体系——马歇尔经济学原理的启示[J].经济论坛.2010(6)
    [35]刘斌.广东农民工职业教育的办学模式绩效评价及其目标定位[J].南方农村,2011(2)
    [36]孙金峰.后人口红利时代新生代农民工职业教育与培训研究[J].成人教育,2011(10)
    [37]张志增.论新生代农民工职业教育[J].教育与职业·理论版,2011(13)
    [38]孙苏贵等.新生代农民工职业教育需求状况实证调查与对策分析——以江苏常州为例[J].商业文化(上半月),2011(10)
    [39]邵艾群.女性农民工的职业教育探析[J].教育学术月刊,2011(6)
    [40]李捷等.我国青年农民工职业发展对策分析[J].襄樊学院学报,2009(12):47-50
    [41]钟洪亮.返乡农民工职业发展的优化策略[J].江西农业大学学报社科版,2009(9):42-46
    [42]国务院研究室课题组.中国农民工调研报告[M].中国言实出版社,2006
    [43]“农民工”在中国经济中的十大历史性贡献[J].长安,2006(4):55-55
    [44]何晓红.农民工的贡献与深圳特区发展[J].特区经济,2006(4)
    [45]农民工为城市创造了多少财富[J].三农,2005(5):21-21
    [46]李强.农民工与中国社会分层[M].社会科学文献出版社,2004.
    [47]温家宝:推动户籍改革让部分农民工融入城市http://news.sohu.com/20100227/ n270465983.shtml
    [48]刘传江,徐建玲等.中国农民工市民化进程研究[M].人民出版社,2008
    [49]杰弗里·萨克斯著/邹光译.贫穷的终结:我们时代的经济可能[M].上海人民出版社,2005
    [50]同[46]
    [51]赵聚军.果实并非如此诱人——从农民工内部诸群体的差异性看中国的城市化进程[J].调研世界,2006(1):14-18
    [52]文军.从季节性流动到劳动力移民:城市农民工群体的分化及其系统构成[J].探索与争鸣,2006(1):28-30
    [53]刘精明.现代化背景下中国农民的职业流动研究,载李培林主编.农民工——中国进程农民工的经济社会分析[M].社会科学文献出版社,2003
    [54]乔尚奎.关于农民工特殊贡献、发展趋势和政策思路的几点认识[J].山东经济战略研究,2006(6):4-8
    [55]同[5]
    [56]同[48]
    [57]形势要点:未来5亿流动人口挑战国内就业统计制度http://hi.baidu.com/ye6425 fang/blog/item/18e5c72a77a35725d52af17b.html
    [58]张国胜.中国农民工市民化:社会成本视角的研究[M].人民出版社2008,8
    [59]唐茂华.对我国两栖劳动力转移模式的理论解释[J].社会科学战线,2005(4):9-65
    [60]简新华等.中国工业化和城市化过程中的农民工问题研究[M].人民出版社,2008
    [61]同[13]
    [62]同[2]
    [63]西蒙,管理行为:管理组织决策过程的研究[M].北京经济学院出版社,1988
    [64]严新明.生存与发展:中国农民发展的社会时空分析[M].社会科学文献出版社,2005
    [65]陆学艺.“三农”论:当代中国农业、农村、农民研究[M].社会科学文献出版社,2002
    [66]同[49]
    [67]李英东.进城农民工的类型差异与政府政策实施[J].农业经济导刊,2006(2):60-64
    [68]韩俊.棋子、边缘人、产业工人[J].农业经济问题,2004(8)
    [69]http://cq.xinhuanet.com/news/2010-11/24/content_21471382.htm10:00:12 2010-11-24来源:重庆晚报“第一眼”。
    [70]钱正武.第二代农民工的主观诉求与政策建议[J].中国青年研究,2006(4):18-20
    [71]ED w in L.Herr.Career Development and Its Practice:A Historical Perspective [J].The Career Development Quarterly,2001,196-211
    [72]王博.职业发展中的“人-职匹配”演化过程与职业指导的模式创新[J],江苏技术师范学院学报,2009(12):5-9
    [73]同[9]
    [74]黄仁贤.黄炎培职业指导理论与实践简论[J],发展研究,1994(7):4-26,43-45
    [75]Mmoeller J.Tubadji A.The Creative Class,Bohemians and Local Market Performance-A Micro-Data Panel Study for Germany 1975-2004 [J/OL].http:// wm 14.263.net/xmeb,2009/10/03,18
    [76]廖根深.当代青年职业流动周期的研究——兼论当代中国青年职业发展的三个阶段[J].中国青年研究,2010(1):5-40
    [77]周群华,厉敏萍.农村剩余劳动力转移的教育成本收益分析[J].商业时代2006(33):11
    [78]加里·贝克尔.人力资本理论[M].中信出版社,2007
    [79]萧鸣政.人力资源开发学——开发组织内人力资源的理论和方法[M].高等教育出版社,2002
    [80]李娟.基于胜任素质的多重职业发展通道体系[J].人力资源,2009(3):7,278
    [81]路德珍.女性人力资源优先开发与管理的战略思考[J].中华女子学院学报,1999(3):40-43
    [82]Chiswiek,Barry."The Effects of Americanization on the Earnings of Foreign born Men", Journal Of Political economy, No.5,1978
    [83]西奥多·W·舒尔茨.人力资本投资—教育和研究的作用[M].商务印书馆1990:28-31
    [84]Robert M Solow "Applying growth theory across countries",the world bank economic review 2001
    [85]亚当·斯密.国民财富的性质和原因的研究(上卷).商务印书馆,1972:257-258
    [86]汪丁丁.记住未来:经济学家的知识社会学[M].社会科学文献出版社,2001:53
    [87]殷德生.报酬递增、动态比较优势与产业内贸易[M].经济科学出版社,2006.
    [88]Romer,Paul M.(1987),"Growths Based on Increasing Return Due to Specialization,"American Eeonomic Review,77,56-62.以及早期的 Arrow(1962)
    [89]Arrow K. The economic Implications of Learning by Doing. Review of Eeonomie Studies,1962,(29)
    [90]Romer P. Increasing Returns and Long-Run Growth. Journal of Politieal Eeonomy, 1986,94(5):1002-1037
    [91]张新博士论文.人力资本_技术进步与内生经济增长——理论及中国实证.2007
    [92]white, Harrisone C,1981,"where do Markets come From?"American Journal of socialgy,87
    [93]莫洛·F纪廉.新经济社会学:一门新兴学科的发展[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2006:8
    [94](法)皮埃尔·布迪厄、[美]华康德著.李猛、李康译.实践与反思——反思社会学导论[M].北京:中央文献出版社,1998:134
    [95]高和荣.现代西方经济社会学理论述评[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2006:213
    [96](美)科尔曼著.邓方译.社会理论的基础(下)[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999:758
    [97](美)普特南著.繁荣的社群:社会资本与公共生活[A].李惠斌、杨雪冬.社会资本与社会发展[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2000:35-36.
    [98](美)法兰西斯·福山著.李婉容译.信任——社会道德与繁荣的创造[M].远方出版社,1998
    [99]胡必亮.关系共同体[M].北京:人民出版社,2005:9
    [100](美)琳南著.张磊译.社会资本——关于社会结构与行动的理论[M].上海:上海人民出版,2005:2
    [101]梁漱溟.中国文化要义[M].上海:学林出版社,2000:93
    [102]费孝通.乡土中国,生育制度[M].北京大学出版社,1998:25
    [103]张晓燕等.基于性别差异的职业发展影响因素研究[J].中国矿业大学学报:社会科 学版,2009(1):86-90
    [104]四川新闻网:“最牛川籍农民工”百万年薪老板“三顾茅庐",2009-08-17
    [105]国家统计局人口与就业统计司编.中国人口统计年鉴2005[M].中国统计出版社,2005:320
    [106]刘传江.中国农民工市民化研究[J].理论月刊,2006(10):5-12
    [107]周其仁.收入是一连串事件[M].北京大学出版社,2006
    [108]李明华.从教育市场大趋势看阿波罗模式在中国的适用性[J].高等教育研究,2006(3):40-46
    [109]胡小凤.MES课程模式:农民工培训的必然选择[J].中国培训,2006(2):62-63
    [110]张楠.微小企业主知识素质培养存在的问题、原因及对策[J].天津工程师范学院学报,2007(2):36-37
    [111]崔卫国,刘学虎.个人发展经济学——关于个人的科学发展观[M].经济科学出版社,2006
    [112]石良平.中级宏观经济学[M].上海财经大学出版社,2004
    [113]同[111]
    [114]黄先海.蛙跳型经济增长——后发国发展路径及中国的选择[M].经济科学出版社,2005
    [115]R.Findlay.1973, "International Trade and Development Theory" [M].New York, Columbia University Press,105
    [116]谢季坚,刘承平.模糊数学方法及其应用[M].华中科技大学出版社,2006
    [117]樊换换,张凌云,Eviews统计分析与应用[M].机械工业出版社,,2010
    [118]同[80]
    [119]尤建新等.质量管理学[M].科学出版社,2003
    [120]同[50]
    [121]张德元.农村“知识贫困”与教育资源配置[J].经济前沿,2003(10):40
    [122]袁银传.小农意识与中国现代化[M].武汉出版社,2008
    [123]news.timedg.com/2011-04/197content_3660033.htm
    [124]同[60]
    [125]刘叶云,游钊.中国新生代农民工就业能力评价体系的构建[J].湖南农业大学学报(社会科学版),2011(2):35-39
    [126]刘道玉.彻底整顿高等教育十意见书.南方周末,2009-02-26
    [127]陈国良,中国人力资源开发与教育发展战略研究报告[M].上海世纪出版集团上海人民出版社,2007
    [128]同[127]
    [129]蔡昉.怎么创造中国的第二次人口红利,南方周末,2009.11.12 F31转引自文汇报,11月9日
    [130]文正东等.对我国农村剩余劳动力转移的介绍和教育理论述评[J].河南师范大学学报(教育科学版),2006,25(1):12-17
    [131]陶潜毅.关于高职院校职后教青与培训的思考[J].中国培训,2006(10)
    [132]李亚芹等.边缘化危机:农民工教育与培训的现实境况分析[J].职教通讯,2007(1):10-12
    [133]蔡泽伟.姚奇富.高职教育要为现代制造业培训技能型人才[J].高等教育研究,2007,28(1):64-66
    [134]苻城.创造教育史上的奇迹——中央广播电视大学30年改革发展综述[J].中华儿女,2011(5):62-64.
    [135]中国农民工问题研究总报告[J],改革,2006(5):5-30

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700