用户名: 密码: 验证码:
冰雪条件下信号交叉口通行能力研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
冰雪天气是我国北方冬季普遍会遇到的气候现象,冰雪天气包括降雪状态和冰冻状态。在降雪期间,雪花影响驾驶员视线,降低路面摩擦系数,车辆行驶环境恶劣,驾驶员驾驶舒适性变差、操作变复杂;在降雪之后,路面在昼夜交替时结冰,驾驶员在信号交叉口红绿灯转换之间制动操作复杂、舒适度降低;这些情况都容易使驾驶员出现精神紧张、视觉疲劳等不舒适感觉,交通运行效率与行车安全性均较正常路面低。国内外研究表明,开展冰雪条件下信号交叉口通行能力的研究对于道路规划、防灾抗灾、提高路网运行效率有着重要作用。
     根据降雪强度分别研究了正常天气、小雪、中雪、大雪、暴雪天气下冰雪路面的基本特征,并根据调查数据分析了冰雪条件对路段通行能力的影响。分别建立了降雪条件下能见度同降雪强度、摩擦系数与降雪厚度、摩擦系数同冰冻强度的关系模型,同时建立了降雪和冰冻条件下路段车流速度模型。
     将冰雪路面分为降雪条件、冰冻条件、降雪和冰冻条件,在此基础上剖析了冰雪条件下信号交叉口的交通流特性模式,通过交通调研、数据分析,研究不同冰雪条件下的路面特性和信号交叉口的交通流特性,包括冰雪条件下速度、路面摩擦系数、穿越间隙等,进行不同冰雪条件下的相互比较以及同正常天气条件相应特性的研究对比。
     从交叉口信号控制出发,分别研究了信号周期时长和绿信比的优化方法,以冰雪条件下的排队长度为判定依据,引入信号交叉口需要优化的判定矩阵,从而确立冰雪条件下信号配时中的周期时长和绿灯时长优化方案,并考虑实际冰雪条件下驾驶的难度和车辆运行特征,采用轨迹法和车辆速度特征优化黄灯时长,完成冰雪条件下信号交叉口的配时优化方案。以哈尔滨市典型交叉口嵩山路-淮河路和红旗大街-淮河路的数据为例,利用Vissim仿真软件对优化方案进行仿真研究。
     以冰雪条件为出发点,在信号配时优化的基础上,分析研究了影响交叉口通行能力的主要因素,包括气候因素、车道功能因素和车道宽度因素。在此基础上,分别基于HCM法和停车线法对信号交叉口通行能力的计算模型进行了修正。在HCM法的基础上,将影响冰雪条件下信号交叉口通行能力的因素综合考虑,标定了冰雪条件下影响信号交叉口通行能力的综合参数;在停车线法的基础上,对各参数进行标定,按照降雪天气和冰冻条件进行分类研究各参数,并给出了各种状态下的参数值。通过修正后的模型计算降雪、冰冻以及降雪和冰冻条件下信号交叉口的通行能力,并对模型计算结果和实际观测值进行比较。
     标定了冰雪条件下信号交叉口的延误模型,主要反映在能见度和摩擦系数对服务水平的影响上,并将其作为信号交叉口服务水平评价的一个重要指标。通过调查数据的整理分析,建立了冰雪条件下信号交叉口车辆到达率的修正系数,其主要考核因素为能见度和摩擦系数,最后标定了不同权重下该修正系数的各个参数。在现有服务水平评价体系基础上,从层次分析的角度建立了冰雪条件下信号交叉口服务水平评价的指标体系,提出了评价标准建议。最后对“十”字型信号交叉口和“T”字型信号交叉口在冰雪条件下的服务水平进行了评价,验证信号配时优化后冰雪条件下交叉口服务水平的变化。
During the snowing, the snowflakes would affect the driver’s sight, reduce friction coefficient of pavement, make the vehicle traffic environment worse, lesson the driving comfort and make the operation complicate; After the snowing, the road will froze which makes the braking operation complicate and lesson the comfort during the signal intersection traffic light conversion; It’s easy for the driver to be uncomforTable, just like nervous and visual fatigue, etc. While the traffic efficiency and traffic security is lower than the normal pavement. The researches at home and abroad show that the study on the Signal intersection capacity in the snow have an important role on the improving road planning, preventing and fighting natural adversities and improving the efficiency of the network.
     According to snowfall intensity, basic features of the ice and snow road under the conditions of normal weather, light snow, moderate snow, heavy snow and extremely heavy snow are studied respectively. Based on the survey data, the influence of the ice and snow conditions on the road traffic capacity is analyzed as well with the establishment of the relationship mode between the visibility under snow condition and the snowfall intensity, friction coefficient, as well as the visibility between the snowfall thickness, friction coefficient, and the freezing intensity. Meanwhile, the traffic flow rate mode on the ice and snow conditions is built.
     The ice and snow conditions can be divided into three types, namely, snowing, freezing and ice-snow mixture. The traffic flow feature mode of the signal intersection under such condition is analyzed on this basis. Through traffic survey and data analysis, the road features under different ice-snow conditions and the traffic flow features of signal intersections are studied, which includes the rate, road friction coefficient and crossing gap under ice-snow conditions. As a result, a comparative study is carried out for the corresponding features under ice-snow conditions and normal weather conditions.
     Based on the intersection signal control, we respectively studied cycle length and split optimization method. According to the snow and ice conditions of queue length to determine the basis, we introduce matrix needed to determine the optimal signal intersection. Therefore, we established the signal timing of the cycle length and green light time optimization solution in the ice and snow condition. And considering the actual difficulties of driving and vehicle running characteristics under the snow and ice conditions,locus method is used to optimize the yellow light time and vehicle speed characteristics, and complete intersection signal timing optimization scheme under the condition of ice and snow. Take a typical intersection-Huaihe road in Harbin and Songshan road, Hongqi street-Huaihe road data for examples, we use the VISSIM simulation software, make the simulation study on the optimization scheme.
     For the signal intersection capacity in the snow and ice conditions, we consider the snow and ice conditions as a starting point and base on the signal timing optimization, analyzing the main factors which influence the intersection capacity, including climate, lane function and width. On this basis, respectively, based on HCM method and stop line method, we correct the signal intersection capacity calculation. Based on the HCM method, we overall consider the factors which affect signal intersection capacity in the ice and snow condition and calibrate the overall parameters which affect the signal intersection capacity in the snow and ice conditions. On the basis of stop line method, we calibrate variable parameters, respectively study on variable parameters according to snow weather and frozen conditions and present parameter values in the different conditions. Through the revised model, we calculate the traffic capacity of signal intersection, compare various capacities under the condition of ice and snow, and compared with normal signal intersection traffic capacity in the normal weather.
     Calibration signal intersection delay model under the condition of ice and snow, which mainly reflected in the visibility and the friction coefficient’s impact on service level, and use it as a signal of an important index of evaluating intersection service level. Through the analysis of survey data and esTablelishing signal intersection traffic arrival rate correction coefficient in the ice and snow condition according to actual situation, its main evaluation factors are visibility and friction coefficient, and finally calibrate under the different weights the correction coefficient of each parameter. On the basis of existing main service level evaluation system, based on the hierarchical analysis,we esTablelish signal road intersection service level's evaluation index system, at the same time we introduce the selecting process of each index in the evaluation system and evaluation standard. And use the method for Huaihe road, Hongqi street and compare and overall evaluate the intersection signal timing optimization in operation condition, and validate intersection service level after the signal timing optimization under the condition of ice and snow road.
引文
[1] Texas Transportation Institute.2010Annual Urban Mobility Report[R]. TexasA&M University,2010. http://mobility.tamu.edu.
    [2]陈晓明.混合交通条件下城市道路信号交叉口通行能力理论研究[D].北京交通大学博士学位论文,2008:2-10.
    [3] Transportation research board.Highway Capacity Manual, Special Report209[R].Washington.D.C: National Research Council,2000:778-813.
    [4]李开兵.城市交通系统抗震防灾规划研究[D].同济大学博士学位论文,2007:2-15.
    [5] Tang Lian-Sheng, Cheng Wen-Ming, Zhang Ze-Qiang, Liang Jian. VehicleRouting Problem with Travel Time Reliability Constrain[C]. InternationalConference on Transportation Engineering, Chengdu,China,2007.Reston,American Society of Civil Engineers,2007:1831-1836.
    [6] Y. Asakura. Evaluation of Network Reliability Using Stochastic UserEquilibrium[J]. Journal of Advanced Transportation.1999,33(2):147-158.
    [7] Transportation Research Board. Highway Capacity Manua[M]. TransportationResearch Board,Washington, D. C.,2000:78-81.
    [8] Transportation Research Board. Traffic Flow Theory[R]. Transportation ResearchBoard Special Report165,1975.
    [9]熊志华.道路网行程时间可靠性基础理论与方法研究[D].北京交通大学博士学位论文,2006:1-5.
    [10] Carlos Canudas-de-wit, Panagiotis Tsiotras. Dynamic Friction Models forRoad/Tire Longitudinal Interaction[J].Vehicle System Dynamics,2002,9(14):1-35.
    [11]河野达也,曹元礼.轮胎在冰雪路面上的摩擦特性和无防滑钉轮胎的技术[J].橡胶参考资料,1997(07):763-769.
    [12] FHWA. Report Economic Impact of Highway Snow and Ice Control FinalReport[R]. FHWA-RD-77-95,1977.
    [13] Ries G. L.Impact of Weather on Freeway Capacity[R].Minneapolis,MN:Minnesota Department of Transportation. Office of Traffic Engineering,1981:178-183.
    [14] Hall F. L. and Barrow. Effects of Weather and the Relationship between Flow andOccupancy on Freeways[R]. Transportation Research Record1194. NationalResearch Council,1988: L55-63.
    [15] Ibrahim A. T. and F.L.Hall.Effect of Adverse Weather Conditions onSpeed-Flow-Occupancy Relationships[R].Transportation Research Record1457.1994:184-191.
    [16] Liang W.L., M.Kyte, F.Kitchener and P. Shannon. The Effect of EnvironmentalFactors on Driver Speed: A Case Study[J].Transportation Research Record1635.1998,155-161.
    [17] Knapp, K.and L. Smithson. The Use of Mobile Video Data Collection Equipmentto Investigate Winter Weather Vehicle Speeds[C].Presented at the80th AnnualTRB Meeting,Transportation Research Board, National Research Council,WashingtonD.C,2001.
    [18]林雨,方守恩.灾害天气环境下高等级公路车速管理[J].自然灾害学报.2007,16(5):96-99.
    [19]高华.城市道路条件及环境对交通安全的影响研究[D].西南交通大学硕士学位论文,2007.
    [20]刘清.高速公路交通灾害预警管理系统研究[D].武汉理工大学博士学位论文,2004.
    [21]罗丽君,高晗,裴玉龙.冰雪道路条件下最小安全行车间距的确定[J].黑龙江交通科技,1999,38:33-34.
    [22]冷军强,张亚平,韩丽飞,张伟.冰雪条件下城市路网容量可靠性[J].哈尔滨工业大学学报.2012,42(4):592-596.
    [23]蒋贤才,裴玉龙.寒冷地区道路交通安全特征及其管理措施分析[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2007,7(4):82-89.
    [24]任园园.冰雪条件下城市道路交通流特性及管理对策研究[D].吉林大学硕士学位论文,2008.
    [25]程国柱,莫宣艳,毛程远.冰雪条件下城市道路交通安全评价方法研究.交通运输系统工程与信息[J].2011,11(1):130-134.
    [26]邢恩辉,王冰.冰雪道路环境对驾驶人视觉感知特性的影响[J].中国安全科学学报,2012,22(3):86-92.
    [27] Transportation research board. Highway Capacity Manual, Special Report209[R].Washington.D.C., National Research Council,1985.
    [28] MilazzoII J S,Rouphail N M, Hummer J E, Allen D P. Effect of Pedestrians onCapacity of Signalized Intersections[J]. Transportation Research Record,1998.
    [29] A F Al-Kaisy, J A Stewart. New Approach for Developing Warrants of ProtectedLeft-turn Phase at Signalized Intersections[J]. Transportation Research, part A,2001,35(6):561-576.
    [30]杨锦冬,杨东援.城市信号控制交叉口信号周期时长优化模型.同济大学学报[J].2001,29(7):789-794.
    [31]万绪军,陆化普.线控系统中相位差优化模型的研究[J].中国公路学报,2001,14(2):100-103.
    [32]金勇,姚荣涵.单点交叉口固定信号配时优化模型[J].大连交通大学学报.2011:6:48-54.
    [33] Vlahogianni E I, Karlaftis M. Optimized and Meta-optimized Neural Networks forShort-term Traffic Flow Prediction: A genetic Approach[J]. Transportation ResearchPart C,2005,13(3):211-234.
    [34]何永明,亓祎,于华洲,孙伟.冰雪条件下信号交叉口通行能力衰减仿真分析[J].交通标准化.2011,9:65-69.
    [35]隽海民,裴玉龙,朱从坤.冰雪覆盖条件下城市道路通行能力分析[J].哈尔滨建筑大学学报.1998,31(2):104-108.
    [36]张锦生,张大力.寒冷地区路面状况影响道路通行能力的探讨[J].林业建设,1997,244(9):164-167.
    [37] Bernardin, Lochmueller and Associates, Inc. Anchorage Signal SystemUpgrade—Final report[R],1995.
    [38] Maki, P.J. Adverse. Weather Traffic Signal Timing[C].69th Annual Meeting of theInstitute of Transportation Engineers, Lasvegas, Nevada,1999.
    [39] Parsonson, Peter S. Flashing Operation and Signal Timing for Adverse Weather[R].NCHRP Synthesis of Highway Practice,,1992:46-47.
    [40] Botha, J.L. and T. R.Kruse. Flow Rates at Signalized intersections Under ColdWinter Conditions[J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering,1992:439-450.
    [41] Gillam, W.J and R.A.Withill. UTC and Inclement Weather Conditions[C]. IEEConference,1992:85-88.
    [42] Hunt P.B, Robertson D.I.Bretherton R.D., Winton R.I. SCOOT-A trafficresponsive method of coordinating signals[R]. TRRL Report LR1014, Crowthorne,1981.
    [43] Perrin, J. P. T. Martin, and B.G. Hansen. Modifying Signal Timing During62Inclement Weather[J]. Transportation Research Record1748,2001.
    [44] Knoblauch, Pietrucha, and Nitzburg. Field Studies of Pedestrian Walking Speedand Start-Up Time[C]. Transportation Research Board No.1538,1994:27-38.
    [45] Gartner, N.H., C.Stamatiadis, and P. J. Tarnoff. Development of adaptive signalcontrol strategies for intelligent transportation systems: a multilevel design[C]. the74th annual meeting of the Transportation Research Board,1995.
    [46] Transportation Research Center.TRANSYT-7F Users Guide[R]. University ofFlorida.Gainesville, Florida,1998.
    [47] Hansen, B., Martin, P., Perrin, J. SCOOT Real-Time Adaptive Control in aCORSIM Simulation Environment[C].Transportation Research Board.2000Annual Conference,Washington,D.C,2000.
    [48]杨龙海,章锡俏,李维,刘缤璘.冰雪条件下信号交叉口交通拥堵扩散范围估计[J].武汉理工大学学报,2012,34(6):63-67.
    [49]胡明伟.不良天气对交通信号配时的影响分析[J].交通标准化,2007,169:156-160.
    [50]冯树民.城市行人过街交通特性与设施设置方法研究[D].哈尔滨工业大学博士学位论文,2006.
    [51]李维.冰雪条件下城市道路网交通流状态演变研究[D].哈尔滨工业大学硕士学位论文,2010.
    [52] Transportation Research Board. Highway Capacity Manual[M]. Washington. D.C:National Research Council,1985.
    [53] Transportation Research Board. Highway Capacity Manual[M]. Washington. D.C:National Research Council,1994.
    [54] Teply S, Allingham D I, Richardson D B, Stephenson B W. Canadian CapacityGuide for Signalized Intersections. Committee on Canadian Capacity Guide forSignalized Intersections[M]. Institute of Transportation Engineers,1995.
    [55] Bang Karl-Lennart. Swedish Capacity Manual: Capacity of SignalizedInterseetions[J]. Transportation Research Record,1979,667:137-146.
    [56] Akeelik R. Calibrating SIDRA, Report ARR180[R]. Vermont South, Victoria,Australia: ARRB Transport Research,1990.
    [57] Handbuch fuer die Bemessung von Strassenverkehrsanlagen(HBS),Edition2001[R]. Cologne, Germany: Forsehungsgesellsehaft fuer StrassemindVerkehrswesen,2001.
    [58] Directorate General of Highways. Indonesian Highway Capacity Manual[M].Ministry of Public Works,1993.
    [59] Mcshane W R, Roess R P,Prassas E S. Traffic Engineering[M].Upper Saddle River,New Jersey: Prentice Hall,1998.
    [60] David Huseh, John Albeek. Intersection Capacity Utilization-EvaluationProcedures for Intersections and Interchanges,2003Edition[M]. Traffic ware Corp,2003.
    [61] Zhang Lin. Signalized intersection level-of-service that accounts for userPerceptions[D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Hawaii,2004.
    [62] Zhang Lin. Fuzzy logic-based user Perceptions of signalized intersection level ofservice[C]. The86th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board,Washington D.C.,2007.
    [63] Flannery A, Pedersen N. Incorporating Customer Perceptions and satisfaction intodetermination of level of service[C]. Proceeding of84th anual Meeting of theTransportation Research Board, Transportation Research Board, WashingtonD.C.2005.
    [64] Zhang Lin, Prevedouros P D. Signalized Intersection Level of Serviceincorporating safety risk[J].Transportation Researeh Record,2003,No.1852:77-86.
    [65] Zhang Lin, Prevedouros P D. Signalized intersection LOS that accounts for userPereePtions[C]. The83th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board,Washington D.C.,2004.
    [66] LI J, Yue Z Q, Wong S C. Performance evaluation of signalized urban intersectionsunder mixed traffic conditions by gray system theory[J]. Journal of TransportationEngineering,130(l),2004.
    [67] Lee Dongmin.Kim Tae-Gyu, Pietrucha M T. Incorporation o ftransportation userPerception into the evaluation of service quality of signalized intersections usingfuzzy aggregation[J]. Transportation Research Reeord,2007, No.2027:9-18.
    [68]陈宽民,严宝杰.道路通行能力分析[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2003.
    [69]张起森,张亚平.道路通行能力分析[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2002.
    [70]张亚平.道路通行能力理论[M].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2007.
    [71]中国公路学会.交通工程手册[M].北京:人民交通出版社,1998.
    [72]中华人民共和国交通部.公路工程技术标准[S].北京:人民交通出版杜,2001.
    [73]汪欣国,倪立.城市道路交叉口评价体系探讨[J].城市轨道交通研究,1999:38-39.
    [74]李妲,邵春福,陈晓明.基于模糊神经网络的信号交叉口服务水平模型[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2009,9(4):127-128.
    [75]姚树中,齐攀.城市信号控制评价指标浅析[J].科技信息,1999(13):544.
    [76]任福田,刘小明,荣建,交通工程学[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2003.
    [77]王素欣,王雷震,高利,崔小光,陈雪梅. BPR路阻函数的研究[J].武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版),2009,33(3):446-449.
    [78]许良,高自友.基于路段能力可靠性的城市交通网络设计[J].中国公路学报,2006,19(2):86~90.
    [79] Hong,Oguchi.Effects of Rainfall and Heavy Vehicles on Speed-Flow Relationshipfor Multilane Expressways in Japan[R]. TRB, National Research Council,Washington D.C.,1994.
    [80] http://zhidao.baidu.com/question/16968358.html.
    [81]刘凯.沥青路面温度场分布规律研究[D].长安大学硕士学位论文,2010.
    [82]李长城,刘小明,荣建.不同路面状况对路面摩擦系数影响的试验研究[J].公路交通科技,2010,27(12),27-32.
    [83] C. Canudas-de-Wit,P. Tsiotras&E. Velenis.Dynamic Friction Models forLongitudinal Road/Tire Interaction Experimental Results[J].Vehicle SystemDynamics,2002,9(14):1-35.
    [84]叶瑞敏.冰雪条件下城市道路纵坡设计指标研究[D].哈尔滨工业大学硕士学位论文,2010年.
    [85]中华人民共和国公安部.中华人民共和国公共安全行业标准—道路交通信号控制[S], GA47—2002:2002.
    [86] William R.McShane, Roger P.Roess and Elena S.Prassas. Traffic Engineering,Second Edition[M]. Prentice Hall,1998.
    [87]栗红强.城市交通控制信号配时参数优化方法研究[D].吉林大学硕士学位论文,2004.
    [88]潘晓东,陈丽烨.直行非机动车避让右转车辆轨迹分析[J].交通科学与工程,2011,27(4),40-44.
    [89]钱大琳,钮志强.混合交通信号交叉口右转机动车通行能力及其敏感度分析[J].中国公路学报,2010,23(2):77-83.
    [90]景春光,曲大义,梁春岩.两相位交叉口机非冲突对机动车饱和流率的影响研究[J].公路交通科技,2007,24(8):124-127.
    [91] Zhang X, Guo Y M, Yang X K.A Model of Potential Capacity of Right TurnMovement at Signalized Intersections Under Mixed TrafficConditions.Transportation Research Board[C].3rd Urban Street Symposium:Uptown, Downtown, or Small Town: Designing Urban Street ThatWork.Washington D.C.TRB,2007:1-13.
    [92]翟忠民.道路交通组织优化[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2004.
    [93]成卫,张瑾,姜华平.信号交叉口左转保护—许可相位转换阈值研究[J].昆明理工大学学报(理工版),2003,6:65-70.
    [94]陈宽民,罗志忠.平面交叉口左转车流的特性分析及对策研究[J].公路交通技术,2006,02:57-62.
    [95]唐彩梅,张俊德.平面交叉口左转车道设计方法研究[J].甘肃科技,2010,11:54-60.
    [96]邵长桥,杜晓辉,李光芹.信号交叉口排队离散车头时距统计分析[J].公路交通科技,2003,20(4):76-79.
    [97]苏岳龙,魏铮,姚丹亚,张毅.混合交通流条件下信号交叉口配时优化设计[J].公路交通科技,2008,25(7):113-117.
    [98] Liu H.C. Balke K.N., Lin W.H. A Reverse Causal Effect Modeling Approach forSignal control of an oversaturated Intersection[J]. Transportation Research Part C,2008,16(6):742-754.
    [99]刘明君.基于混合交通流的信号交叉口机动车车头时距研究[D].北京交通大学博士学位论文,2012.
    [100] Lin F. B., Thomas D. R. Headway Compression During Queue Discharge atSignalized Intersections[R]. Transportation Research Record,2005, No.1920:81-85.
    [101]蒲琪,谭永朝,杨超.交叉口信号配时优化模型研究[J].上海铁道大学学报,1999,20(4):31-34.
    [102]李克平,杨佩昆.城市道路交叉口信号控制中的黄灯问题[J].城市交通,2010,8(4):67-72.
    [103] Yafeng Yin. Robust Optimal Traffic Signal Timing[J]. Transportation ResearchPart B,2008,42:911-924.
    [104]马建明,任福田,刘小明,荣建.信号交叉口交通组织优化设计[J].北京工业大学学报,2001,27(2):237-239.
    [105]曾伟良,何兆成.交叉口信号控制模型指标权重的确定方法.公路交通科技(应用技术版)[J].2012,9:45-49.
    [106]高云峰,徐立鸿,汪涛,韩皓.交叉口信号控制方案评价指标动态估计模型.同济大学学报(自然科学版)[J],2011,6:51-55.
    [107]邵长桥,荣建.停车延误、引道延误和控制延误关系研究[J].中国公路学报,2002,15(4):90-93.
    [108]F. V. Webster and B. M. Cobbe. Traffic Signals[C]. Road Research TechnicalPaper No.56,HMSO, London.U.K,1996.
    [109]马建明.信号交叉口优化设计及其微观仿真研究[D].北京:北京工业大学博士学位论文,2001.
    [110] R.Akcelik.Traffic Signals. Capacity and Timing Analysis[R]. ARRB ResearchRecord No.123. ARRB, Australia,1981.
    [111]杨晓光,杨佩昆.信号灯控制交叉口停车线前停车率模型[J].同济大学学报,1993,21(2):169-175.
    [112]梁樑,盛昭翰,徐南荣.一种的层次分析法[J].系统工程,1989,7(3):5-7.
    [113] Wen Jing jing. Research on Site Selection of Logistics Park Based on FuzzyComprehensive Evaluation Method[C].2010Second International Conference onComputer Engineering and Applications, Haikou China,2010:44-47.
    [114] Pecheux K K. User Perception of time–based level-of-service criteria forsignalized intersection[D]. Ph.D. Dessertation, the Pennsylvania State University,2000.
    [115] Zhang Lin.Fuzzy logic-based user perceptions of signal intersection level ofservice[C]. the86th annual meeting of the transportation researchboard,Washington, D. C,2007.
    [116] Zhang Lin. Signalized intersection level-of–service that accounts for userperception [D]. Ph.D. Dissretation, University of Hawaii,2004.
    [117] Flannery A, Pedersen N. Incorating customer perceptions and satisfaction intodetermination of level of service.proceeding[C].84th annual meeting of thetransportation research board, Washington, D. C.,2005.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700