紫花苜蓿内生和非内生根瘤菌多样性及共生差异
|
摘要
【背景】对根瘤菌多样性的研究有助于推进根瘤菌种质资源的利用。【目的】研究紫花苜蓿内生和非内生根瘤菌的表型和遗传多样性,比较菌株在5个苜蓿品种上的共生效应,验证根瘤菌群体共生效应由苜蓿品种决定的假设。【方法】从甘肃省白银会宁旱作区、兰州安宁灌区、武威凉州灌区3个栽培区域的陇中、清水、WL168HQ、甘农3号、甘农9号等紫花苜蓿品种中分离内生(植株种子、花、叶、茎、根表皮、根中柱和根瘤)和非内生(根际土壤和田间土壤)根瘤菌菌株,通过表型数值分类、 16SrRNA基因限制性片段长度多态性(Restrictionfragmentlengthpolymorphism,RFLP)、16S rRNA基因测序、持家基因多位点序列分型(Multilocus sequence typing,MLST),以及结瘤基因nodC和固氮基因nifH片段序列测定,研究紫花苜蓿根瘤菌的表型和遗传多样性,并采用主成分分析研究根瘤菌菌株在5个紫花苜蓿品种上的共生效应差异。【结果】共分离得到43株内生根瘤菌和10株非内生根瘤菌,叶片和花中没有分离到根瘤菌菌株。53株根瘤菌以及对照菌株R.GN5和S.12531表型特征数值分类聚为8个群,菌株表型多样性丰富。经16SrRNA-RFLP分析共形成22种RFLP分型组合,基因型Ⅰ分布最广泛(24),其次为基因型Ⅻ(5)、ⅩⅤ(5)和ⅩⅨ(3),其余16株菌各代表1种基因型,菌株遗传多样性丰富。16S rRNA基因测序和MLST分析将所有菌株划分为Rhizobiumradiobacter、R.rosettiformans和Ensifermeliloti。仅从7株E.meliloti代表菌株和对照菌株S.12531中扩增到nodC和nifH基因,说明E.meliloti菌株均能结瘤固氮。E.meliloti菌株G3L3接种甘农3号,LP3、LL1和LL2接种陇中,QL2接种清水,LL1、LL2和WLP2接种WL169HQ苜蓿均能显著促进植株的单株结瘤数、地上干重和粗蛋白含量。E.meliloti菌株接种甘农3号、甘农9号和清水苜蓿品种后所有参数值在PC1轴上分别聚在-1-1之间,在PC3轴上聚在-1.5-1.5之间;接种陇中和WL168HQ苜蓿的参数值较分散,PC1轴上分散在-1.5-4之间,PC3轴上分散在-3-4之间。【结论】紫花苜蓿内生和非内生根瘤菌菌株多样性丰富,表型和遗传多样性与其来源没有直接关系。菌株G3L3与甘农3号,LP3、LL1、LL2与陇中,QL2与清水、LL1、LL2、WLP2与WL169HQ苜蓿品种共生匹配和适应能力强。在甘农3号、甘农9号和清水紫花苜蓿品种上群体共生效应相似,在陇中和WL168HQ紫花苜蓿上共生效应差异明显。本研究内生和非内生根瘤菌菌株的群体共生效应根据苜蓿品种而定,根瘤菌菌株与苜蓿品种间的信号识别程度存在差异。
[Background] Research on rhizobium diversity has paved the way for utilization of rhizobial germplasm resources. [Objective] To research the phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia of alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.), and verify the hypothesis that rhizobial symbiotic efficiency differed according to alfalfa variety by comparing their symbiotic difference on five alfalfa varieties. [Methods] Endophytic(seed, flower, leaf, stem, root epidermis, root stele, nodule)and non-endophytic(rhizosphere soil and field soil) bacteria isolates were collected from M. sativa cvs.Longzhong and Qingshui in arid crop area of Huining, Baiyin, M. sativa cv. WL168 HQ in irrigated area of Anning, Lanzhou, and M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3 and Gannong No. 9 in irrigated area of Liangzhou, Wuwei, Gansu. Numerical analysis, 16 S rRNA restriction fragment length polymorphism fingerprinting(RFLP), 16 S rRNA gene sequencing, multilocus sequence typing(MLST) of concatenated sequences of atpD, glnⅡ, and recA genes, and sequence analysis of symbiotic genes nodC and nifH were applied to study the phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia. A principal component analysis(PCA) was used to investigate their symbiotic differences on five alfalfa varieties as well. [Results] Totally 43 endophytes and 10 non-endophytic isolates were obtained. None were collected from flowers and leaves. The phenotypic diversity of these 53 isolates along with two reference strains(R.GN5 and S.12531) were abundant, with eight phenotypic clusters formed.Twenty-two RFLP patterns were produced after 16 S rRNA-RFLP analysis, and the most widespread genotype among the isolates was that designated as genotype Ⅰ(24). Three other genotypes(Ⅻ, ⅩⅤand ⅩⅨ) occurred less frequently in alfalfa symbionts(five, five and three). There were 16 genotypes specific to a single M. sativa isolate. According to the phylogenetic analyses of 16 S rRNA gene and MLST, isolates were further classified into Rhizobium radiobacter, R. rosettiformans, and Ensifer meliloti. The nodC and nifH gene fragments were only amplified and sequenced from seven representative E. meliloti strains and reference strain S.12531, indicating that they were capable of nodulating alfalfa. The nodule number per plant, shoot dry weight and crude protein content of M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3(inoculated with G3 L3), Longzhong(inoculated with LP3, LL1 and LL2), Qingshui(inoculated with QL2), and WL168 HQ(inoculated with LL1, LL2 and WLP2) were promoted simultaneously. The parameter values of M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3, Gannong No. 9, and Qingshui plants inoculated with the E. meliloti isolates clustered together, which ranged from-1 to 1 in PC1 axis and-1.5 to 1.5 in PC3 axis. Compared with these three alfalfa varieties, that of M. sativa cvs.Longzhong and WL168 HQ plants dispersed greatly and ranged from-1.5 to 4 in PC1 axis and-3 to 4 in PC3 axis. [Conclusion] The phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia were abundant, and there was no direct relationship between diversity and strains' origins.Strong mutualistic symbiosis and adaptability were presented between G3 L3 and M. sativa cv. Gannong No. 3, LP3, LL1, LL2 and M. sativa cv. Longzhong, QL2 and M. sativa cv. Qingshui, and LL1, LL2,WLP2 and M. sativa cv. WL168 HQ. The tested strains exhibited similar symbiotic efficiency when inoculated onto M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3, Gannong No. 9, and Qingshui plants, while an obvious symbiotic difference of rhizobial strains was observed in M. sativa cvs. Longzhong and WL168 HQ plants. Their symbiotic efficiency varied according to alfalfa varieties, which manifested that the sensitivity of different alfalfa varieties to rhizobial strains may differ.
[Background] Research on rhizobium diversity has paved the way for utilization of rhizobial germplasm resources. [Objective] To research the phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia of alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.), and verify the hypothesis that rhizobial symbiotic efficiency differed according to alfalfa variety by comparing their symbiotic difference on five alfalfa varieties. [Methods] Endophytic(seed, flower, leaf, stem, root epidermis, root stele, nodule)and non-endophytic(rhizosphere soil and field soil) bacteria isolates were collected from M. sativa cvs.Longzhong and Qingshui in arid crop area of Huining, Baiyin, M. sativa cv. WL168 HQ in irrigated area of Anning, Lanzhou, and M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3 and Gannong No. 9 in irrigated area of Liangzhou, Wuwei, Gansu. Numerical analysis, 16 S rRNA restriction fragment length polymorphism fingerprinting(RFLP), 16 S rRNA gene sequencing, multilocus sequence typing(MLST) of concatenated sequences of atpD, glnⅡ, and recA genes, and sequence analysis of symbiotic genes nodC and nifH were applied to study the phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia. A principal component analysis(PCA) was used to investigate their symbiotic differences on five alfalfa varieties as well. [Results] Totally 43 endophytes and 10 non-endophytic isolates were obtained. None were collected from flowers and leaves. The phenotypic diversity of these 53 isolates along with two reference strains(R.GN5 and S.12531) were abundant, with eight phenotypic clusters formed.Twenty-two RFLP patterns were produced after 16 S rRNA-RFLP analysis, and the most widespread genotype among the isolates was that designated as genotype Ⅰ(24). Three other genotypes(Ⅻ, ⅩⅤand ⅩⅨ) occurred less frequently in alfalfa symbionts(five, five and three). There were 16 genotypes specific to a single M. sativa isolate. According to the phylogenetic analyses of 16 S rRNA gene and MLST, isolates were further classified into Rhizobium radiobacter, R. rosettiformans, and Ensifer meliloti. The nodC and nifH gene fragments were only amplified and sequenced from seven representative E. meliloti strains and reference strain S.12531, indicating that they were capable of nodulating alfalfa. The nodule number per plant, shoot dry weight and crude protein content of M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3(inoculated with G3 L3), Longzhong(inoculated with LP3, LL1 and LL2), Qingshui(inoculated with QL2), and WL168 HQ(inoculated with LL1, LL2 and WLP2) were promoted simultaneously. The parameter values of M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3, Gannong No. 9, and Qingshui plants inoculated with the E. meliloti isolates clustered together, which ranged from-1 to 1 in PC1 axis and-1.5 to 1.5 in PC3 axis. Compared with these three alfalfa varieties, that of M. sativa cvs.Longzhong and WL168 HQ plants dispersed greatly and ranged from-1.5 to 4 in PC1 axis and-3 to 4 in PC3 axis. [Conclusion] The phenotypic and genetic diversity of endophytic and non-endophytic rhizobia were abundant, and there was no direct relationship between diversity and strains' origins.Strong mutualistic symbiosis and adaptability were presented between G3 L3 and M. sativa cv. Gannong No. 3, LP3, LL1, LL2 and M. sativa cv. Longzhong, QL2 and M. sativa cv. Qingshui, and LL1, LL2,WLP2 and M. sativa cv. WL168 HQ. The tested strains exhibited similar symbiotic efficiency when inoculated onto M. sativa cvs. Gannong No. 3, Gannong No. 9, and Qingshui plants, while an obvious symbiotic difference of rhizobial strains was observed in M. sativa cvs. Longzhong and WL168 HQ plants. Their symbiotic efficiency varied according to alfalfa varieties, which manifested that the sensitivity of different alfalfa varieties to rhizobial strains may differ.
引文
[1]Senthilkumar M,Anandham R,Madhaiyan M,et al.Endophytic bacteria:perspectives and applications in agricultural crop production[A]//Maheshwari DK.Bacteria in Agrobiology:Crop Ecosystems[M].Berlin,Heidelberg:Springer,2011:61-96
[2]Tanuja BSC,Mishra PK.Ascending migration of endophytic Bacillus thuringiensis and assessment of benefits to different legumes of N.W.Himalayas[J].European Journal of Soil Biology,2013,56:56-64
[3]Beltran-Garcia MJ,White JF Jr,Prado FM,et al.Nitrogen acquisition in Agave tequilana from degradation of endophytic bacteria[J].Scientific Reports,2014,4:6938
[4]Mabood F,Zhou XM,Smith DL.Microbial signaling and plant growth promotion[J].Canadian Journal of Plant Science,2014,94(6):1051-1063
[5]Pavlo A,Leonid O,Iryna Z,et al.Endophytic bacteria enhancing growth and disease resistance of potato(Solanum tuberosum L.)[J].Biological Control,2011,56(1):43-49
[6]Miliute I,Buzaite O,Baniulis D,et al.Bacterial endophytes in agricultural crops and their role in stress tolerance:a review[J].Zemdirbyste-Agriculture,2015,102(4):465-478
[7]Lodewyckx C,Vangronsveld J,Porteous F,et al.Endophytic bacteria and their potential applications[J].Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences,2002,21(6):583-606
[8]Bacon CW,Hinton DM.Bacterial endophytes:the endophytic niche,its occupants,and its utility[A]//Gnanamanickam SS.Plant-Associated Bacteria[M].Dordrecht:Springer,2006:155-194
[9]Romdhane SB,Trabelsi M,Aouani ME,et al.The diversity of rhizobia nodulating chickpea(Cicer arietinum)under water deficiency as a source of more efficient inoculants[J].Soil Biology and Biochemistry,2009,41(12):2568-2572
[10]Qi J.Screening endogenous rhizobia from alfalfa seeds and their promoting alfalfa seedlings growth property[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2006(in Chinese)祁娟.苜蓿种子内生根瘤菌筛选及其促生能力研究[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2006
[11]Li JF,Zhang SQ,Shi SL,et al.Position and quantity of endogensis rhizobia in alfalfa plant[J].Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2009,17(6):1200-1205(in Chinese)李剑峰,张淑卿,师尚礼,等.苜蓿内生根瘤菌分布部位与数量变化动态[J].中国生态农业学报,2009,17(6):1200-1205
[12]Zhang SQ.Migration of rhizobia inside alfalfa plants and influencing factors[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2012(in Chinese)张淑卿.根瘤菌在苜蓿植株体内的运移及影响因素[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2012
[13]Miao YY,Shi SL,Zhang JG,et al.Migration,colonization and seedling growth of rhizobia with matrine treatment in alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.)[J].Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica,Section B-Soil&Plant Science,2018,68(1):26-38
[14]Muresu R,Polone E,Sulas L,et al.Coexistence of predominantly nonculturable rhizobia with diverse,endophytic bacterial taxa within nodules of wild legumes[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2008,63:383-400
[15]Deng ZS,Zhao LF,Kong ZY,et al.Diversity of endophytic bacteria within nodules of the Sphaerophysa salsula in different regions of Loess plateau in China[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2011,76(3):463-475
[16]Aserse AA,R?s?nen LA,Aseffa F,et al.Phylogenetically diverse groups of Bradyrhizobium isolated from nodules of Crotalaria spp.,Indigofera spp.,Erythrina brucei and Glycine max growing in Ethiopia[J].Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution,2012,65(2):595-609
[17]Xu L,Zhang Y,Wang L,et al.Diversity of endophytic bacteria associated with nodules of two indigenous legumes at different altitudes of the Qilian mountains in China[J].Systematic and Applied Microbiology,2014,37(6):457-465
[18]Qi CM.The study on biodiversity and phylogenesis of rhizobia isolated from Trifolium and Medicago[D].Chengdu:Master’s Thesis of Sichuan Agricultural University,2004(in Chinese)齐春梅.苜蓿、三叶草根瘤菌生物多样性和系统发育地位的研究[D].成都:四川农业大学硕士学位论文,2004
[19]Aserse AA,R?s?nen LA,Aseffa F,et al.Diversity of sporadic symbionts and nonsymbiotic endophytic bacteria isolated from nodules of woody,shrub,and food legumes in Ethiopia[J].Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology,2013,97(23):10117-10134
[20]Cooper JE.Early interactions between legumes and rhizobia:disclosing complexity in a molecular dialogue[J].Journal of Applied Microbiology,2007,103(5):1355-1365
[21]Silva C,Kan FL,Martínez-Romero E.Population genetic structure of Sinorhizobium meliloti and S.medicae isolated from nodules of Medicago spp.in Mexico[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2007,60(3):477-489
[22]Torres TG,Rogel MA,Orme?o-Orrillo E,et al.Rhizobium favelukesii sp.nov.isolated from the root nodules of alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.)[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2016,66(11):4451-4457
[23]Huo PH.Antimicrobial-resistant rhizobia screening and effect verification of undesired microbe control in the prepared rhizobia inoculant[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2014(in Chinese)霍平慧.耐抑菌剂根瘤菌筛选及耐药菌株制备菌剂抑杂菌效果研究[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2014
[24]Qi J,Shi SL.Preliminary Study on the ability of phosphorussolubilizing and IAA-secreting of endogenous rhizobia in seeds of different alfalfa varieties[J].Grassland and Turf,2006(5):18-20,25(in Chinese)祁娟,师尚礼.不同品种紫花苜蓿种子内生根瘤菌溶磷和分泌生长素能力[J].草原与草坪,2006(5):18-20,25
[25]Huo PH,Li JF,Shi SL,et al.Effect of seed ultra-drying storage on growth and resistance of the Medicago sativa seedlings affected by alkaline salt stress[J].Scientia Agricultura Sinica,2014,47(13):2643-2651(in Chinese)霍平慧,李剑峰,师尚礼,等.碱性盐胁迫对超干贮藏苜蓿种子幼苗生长及抗性的影响[J].中国农业科学,2014,47(13):2643-2651
[26]Zhang XF,Shi SL,Nan LL,et al.Phenotype diversities of alfalfa rhizobium strains collected in different ecological regions in Gansu Province[J].Journal of Gansu Agricultural University,2009,44(3):106-111(in Chinese)张小甫,师尚礼,南丽丽,等.甘肃不同生态区域苜蓿根瘤菌表型多样性分析[J].甘肃农业大学学报,2009,44(3):106-111
[27]Weisburg WG,Barns SM,Pelletier DA,et al.16S ribosomal DNAamplification for phylogenetic study[J].Journal of Bacteriology,1991,173(2):697-703
[28]Vinuesa P,Silva C,Lorite MJ,et al.Molecular systematics of rhizobia based on maximum likelihood and Bayesian phylogenies inferred from rrs,atpD,rec A and nifH sequences,and their use in the classification of Sesbania microsymbionts from Venezuelan wetlands[J].Systematic and Applied Microbiology,2005,28(8):702-716
[29]Sarita S,Sharma PK,Priefer UB,et al.Direct amplification of rhizobial nodC sequences from soil total DNA and comparison to nodC diversity of root nodule isolates[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2005,54(1):1-11
[30]Laguerre G,Nour SM,Macheret V,et al.Classification of rhizobia based on nodC and nifH gene analysis reveals a close phylogenetic relationship among Phaseolus vulgaris symbionts[J].Microbiology,2001,147(4):981-993
[31]Wang ET,van Berkum V,Beyene D,et al.Rhizobium huautlense sp.nov.,a symbiont of Sesbania herbacea that has a close phylogenetic relationship with Rhizobium galegae[J].International Journal of Systematic Bacteriology,1998,48(3):687-699
[32]Yoon SH,Ha SM,Kwon S,et al.Introducing ezbiocloud:a taxonomically united database of 16S rRNA gene sequences and whole-genome assemblies[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2017,67(5):1613-1617
[33]Tamura K,Peterson D,Peterson N,et al.MEGA5:molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood,evolutionary distance,and maximum parsimony methods[J].Molecular Biology and Evolution,2011,28(10):2731-2739
[34]Shetta ND,Alshahranil TS.The symbiotic efficiency of legume tree rhizobia for host range legumes in central Saudi Arabia[J].International Journal of Agriculture&Biology,2016,18(4):851-857
[35]Zaied KA,Kosba ZA,Nassef MA,et al.Induction of Rhizobium inoculants harboring salicylic acid gene[J].Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences,2009,3(2):1386-1411
[36]Tang Z,An H,Deng L,et al.Effect of desertification on productivity in a desert steppe[J].Scientific Reports,2016,6:27839
[37]Boukhatem ZF,Domergue O,Bekki A,et al.Symbiotic characterization and diversity of rhizobia associated with native and introduced acacias in arid and semi-arid regions in Algeria[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2012,80(3):534-547
[38]Sachs JL,Kembel SW,Lau AH,et al.In situ phylogenetic structure and diversity of wild Bradyrhizobium communities[J].Applied Environmental Microbiology,2009,75(14):4727-4735
[39]Mengoni A,Pini F,Huang LN,et al.Plant-by-plant variations of bacterial communities associated with leaves of the nickel hyperaccumulator Alyssum bertolonii desv[J].Microbial Ecology,2009,58(3):660-667
[40]Arnold AE.Understanding the diversity of foliar endophytic fungi:progress,challenges,and frontiers[J].Fungal Biology Reviews,2007,21(2/3):51-66
[41]Nandwani R,Dudeja SS.Molecular diversity of a native Mesorhizobial population of nodulating chickpea(Cicer arietinum L.)in Indian soils[J].Journal of Basic Microbiology,2009,49(5):463-470
[42]Leite J,Fischer D,Rouws LFM,et al.Cowpea nodules harbor non-rhizobial bacterial communities that are shaped by soil type rather than plant genotype[J].Frontiers in Plant Science,2017,7:2064
[43]Gnat S,Wójcik M,Wdowiak-Wróbel S,et al.Phenotypic characterization of Astragalus glycyphyllos symbionts and their phylogeny based on the 16S rDNA sequences and RFLP of 16Sr RNA gene[J].Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek,2014,105(6):1033-1048
[44]Wielbo J,Marek-Kozaczuk M,Mazur A,et al.Genetic and metabolic divergence within a Rhizobium leguminosarum bv.trifolii population recovered from clover nodules[J].Applied and Environmental Microbiology,2010,76(14):4593-4600
[45]Wielbo J,Marek-Kozaczuk M,Mazur A,et al.The structure and metabolic diversity of population of pea microsymbionts isolated from root nodules[J].British Microbiology Research Journal,2011,1(3):55-69
[46]Wielbo J.Rhizobial communities in symbiosis with legumes:genetic diversity,competition and interactions with host plants[J].Central European Journal of Biology,2012,7(3):363-372
[47]Tindall BJ.The genus name Sinorhizobium chen et al.1988 is a later synonym of Ensifer casida 1982 and is not conserved over the latter genus name,and the species name‘Sinorhizobium adhaerens’is not validly published.opinion 84[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2008,58(Pt 8):1973
[48]Wang XL,Cui WJ,Feng XY,et al.Rhizobia inhabiting nodules and rhizosphere soils of alfalfa:a strong selection of facultative microsymbionts[J].Soil Biology and Biochemistry,2018,116:340-350
[49]Amadou C,Pascal G,Mangenot S,et al.Genome sequence of theβ-rhizobium Cupriavidus taiwanensis and comparative genomics of rhizobia[J].Genome Research,2008,18(9):1472-1483
[50]Estrella MJ,Munoz S,Soto MJ,et al.Genetic diversity and host range of rhizobia nodulating Lotus tenuis in typical soils of the Salado River Basin(Argentina)[J].Applied and Environmental Microbiology,2009,75(4):1088-1098
[51]Beijerinck MW,van Delden A.Ueber die Assimilation des freien Stickstoffs durch Bakterien[J].Zentbl Bakt Parasitenk Infekt,1902,2:3-43
[52]Tindall BJ.Agrobacterium radiobacter(Beijerinck and van Delden 1902)Conn 1942 has priority over Agrobacterium tumefaciens(Smith and Townsend 1907)Conn 1942 when the two are treated as members of the same species based on the principle of priority and Rule 23a,Note 1 as applied to the corresponding specific epithets.Opinion 94[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2014,64(Pt 10):3590-3592
[53]Conn HJ.Validity of the genus Alcaligenes[J].Journal of Bacteriology,1942,44(3):353-360
[54]Young JM,Pennycook SR,Watson DRW.Proposal that Agrobacterium radiobacter has priority over Agrobacterium tumefaciens.Request for an opinion[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2006,56(2):491-493
[55]Kaur J,Verma M,Lal R.Rhizobium rosettiformans sp.nov.,isolated from a hexachlorocyclohexane dump site,and reclassification of Blastobacter aggregatus Hirsch and Muller1986 as Rhizobium aggregatum comb.nov.[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2011,61(Pt 5):1218-1225
[56]Burbano CS,Liu Y,R?sner KL,et al.Predominant nifH transcript phylotypes related to Rhizobium rosettiformans in field-grown sugarcane plants and in Norway spruce[J].Environmental Microbiology Reports,2011,3(3):383-389
[57]Fortuna MA,Zaman L,Ofria C,et al.The genotype-phenotype map of an evolving digital organism[J].PLoS Computational Biology,2017,13(2):e1005414
[58]Salazar-Ciudad I,Marín-Riera M.Adaptive dynamics under development-based genotype-phenotype maps[J].Nature,2013,497(7449):361-364
[59]Fridgen JL,Varco JJ.Dependency of cotton leaf nitrogen,chlorophyll,and reflectance on nitrogen and potassium availability[J].Agronomy Journal,2004,96(1):63-69
[60]Martínez-Romero E.Coevolution in rhizobium-legume symbiosis?[J].DNA and Cell Biology,2009,28(8):361-370
[61]Doyle JJ.Phylogenetic perspectives on the origins of nodulation[J].Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions,2011,24(11):1289-1295
[2]Tanuja BSC,Mishra PK.Ascending migration of endophytic Bacillus thuringiensis and assessment of benefits to different legumes of N.W.Himalayas[J].European Journal of Soil Biology,2013,56:56-64
[3]Beltran-Garcia MJ,White JF Jr,Prado FM,et al.Nitrogen acquisition in Agave tequilana from degradation of endophytic bacteria[J].Scientific Reports,2014,4:6938
[4]Mabood F,Zhou XM,Smith DL.Microbial signaling and plant growth promotion[J].Canadian Journal of Plant Science,2014,94(6):1051-1063
[5]Pavlo A,Leonid O,Iryna Z,et al.Endophytic bacteria enhancing growth and disease resistance of potato(Solanum tuberosum L.)[J].Biological Control,2011,56(1):43-49
[6]Miliute I,Buzaite O,Baniulis D,et al.Bacterial endophytes in agricultural crops and their role in stress tolerance:a review[J].Zemdirbyste-Agriculture,2015,102(4):465-478
[7]Lodewyckx C,Vangronsveld J,Porteous F,et al.Endophytic bacteria and their potential applications[J].Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences,2002,21(6):583-606
[8]Bacon CW,Hinton DM.Bacterial endophytes:the endophytic niche,its occupants,and its utility[A]//Gnanamanickam SS.Plant-Associated Bacteria[M].Dordrecht:Springer,2006:155-194
[9]Romdhane SB,Trabelsi M,Aouani ME,et al.The diversity of rhizobia nodulating chickpea(Cicer arietinum)under water deficiency as a source of more efficient inoculants[J].Soil Biology and Biochemistry,2009,41(12):2568-2572
[10]Qi J.Screening endogenous rhizobia from alfalfa seeds and their promoting alfalfa seedlings growth property[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2006(in Chinese)祁娟.苜蓿种子内生根瘤菌筛选及其促生能力研究[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2006
[11]Li JF,Zhang SQ,Shi SL,et al.Position and quantity of endogensis rhizobia in alfalfa plant[J].Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2009,17(6):1200-1205(in Chinese)李剑峰,张淑卿,师尚礼,等.苜蓿内生根瘤菌分布部位与数量变化动态[J].中国生态农业学报,2009,17(6):1200-1205
[12]Zhang SQ.Migration of rhizobia inside alfalfa plants and influencing factors[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2012(in Chinese)张淑卿.根瘤菌在苜蓿植株体内的运移及影响因素[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2012
[13]Miao YY,Shi SL,Zhang JG,et al.Migration,colonization and seedling growth of rhizobia with matrine treatment in alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.)[J].Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica,Section B-Soil&Plant Science,2018,68(1):26-38
[14]Muresu R,Polone E,Sulas L,et al.Coexistence of predominantly nonculturable rhizobia with diverse,endophytic bacterial taxa within nodules of wild legumes[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2008,63:383-400
[15]Deng ZS,Zhao LF,Kong ZY,et al.Diversity of endophytic bacteria within nodules of the Sphaerophysa salsula in different regions of Loess plateau in China[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2011,76(3):463-475
[16]Aserse AA,R?s?nen LA,Aseffa F,et al.Phylogenetically diverse groups of Bradyrhizobium isolated from nodules of Crotalaria spp.,Indigofera spp.,Erythrina brucei and Glycine max growing in Ethiopia[J].Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution,2012,65(2):595-609
[17]Xu L,Zhang Y,Wang L,et al.Diversity of endophytic bacteria associated with nodules of two indigenous legumes at different altitudes of the Qilian mountains in China[J].Systematic and Applied Microbiology,2014,37(6):457-465
[18]Qi CM.The study on biodiversity and phylogenesis of rhizobia isolated from Trifolium and Medicago[D].Chengdu:Master’s Thesis of Sichuan Agricultural University,2004(in Chinese)齐春梅.苜蓿、三叶草根瘤菌生物多样性和系统发育地位的研究[D].成都:四川农业大学硕士学位论文,2004
[19]Aserse AA,R?s?nen LA,Aseffa F,et al.Diversity of sporadic symbionts and nonsymbiotic endophytic bacteria isolated from nodules of woody,shrub,and food legumes in Ethiopia[J].Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology,2013,97(23):10117-10134
[20]Cooper JE.Early interactions between legumes and rhizobia:disclosing complexity in a molecular dialogue[J].Journal of Applied Microbiology,2007,103(5):1355-1365
[21]Silva C,Kan FL,Martínez-Romero E.Population genetic structure of Sinorhizobium meliloti and S.medicae isolated from nodules of Medicago spp.in Mexico[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2007,60(3):477-489
[22]Torres TG,Rogel MA,Orme?o-Orrillo E,et al.Rhizobium favelukesii sp.nov.isolated from the root nodules of alfalfa(Medicago sativa L.)[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2016,66(11):4451-4457
[23]Huo PH.Antimicrobial-resistant rhizobia screening and effect verification of undesired microbe control in the prepared rhizobia inoculant[D].Lanzhou:Doctoral Dissertation of Gansu Agricultural University,2014(in Chinese)霍平慧.耐抑菌剂根瘤菌筛选及耐药菌株制备菌剂抑杂菌效果研究[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学博士学位论文,2014
[24]Qi J,Shi SL.Preliminary Study on the ability of phosphorussolubilizing and IAA-secreting of endogenous rhizobia in seeds of different alfalfa varieties[J].Grassland and Turf,2006(5):18-20,25(in Chinese)祁娟,师尚礼.不同品种紫花苜蓿种子内生根瘤菌溶磷和分泌生长素能力[J].草原与草坪,2006(5):18-20,25
[25]Huo PH,Li JF,Shi SL,et al.Effect of seed ultra-drying storage on growth and resistance of the Medicago sativa seedlings affected by alkaline salt stress[J].Scientia Agricultura Sinica,2014,47(13):2643-2651(in Chinese)霍平慧,李剑峰,师尚礼,等.碱性盐胁迫对超干贮藏苜蓿种子幼苗生长及抗性的影响[J].中国农业科学,2014,47(13):2643-2651
[26]Zhang XF,Shi SL,Nan LL,et al.Phenotype diversities of alfalfa rhizobium strains collected in different ecological regions in Gansu Province[J].Journal of Gansu Agricultural University,2009,44(3):106-111(in Chinese)张小甫,师尚礼,南丽丽,等.甘肃不同生态区域苜蓿根瘤菌表型多样性分析[J].甘肃农业大学学报,2009,44(3):106-111
[27]Weisburg WG,Barns SM,Pelletier DA,et al.16S ribosomal DNAamplification for phylogenetic study[J].Journal of Bacteriology,1991,173(2):697-703
[28]Vinuesa P,Silva C,Lorite MJ,et al.Molecular systematics of rhizobia based on maximum likelihood and Bayesian phylogenies inferred from rrs,atpD,rec A and nifH sequences,and their use in the classification of Sesbania microsymbionts from Venezuelan wetlands[J].Systematic and Applied Microbiology,2005,28(8):702-716
[29]Sarita S,Sharma PK,Priefer UB,et al.Direct amplification of rhizobial nodC sequences from soil total DNA and comparison to nodC diversity of root nodule isolates[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2005,54(1):1-11
[30]Laguerre G,Nour SM,Macheret V,et al.Classification of rhizobia based on nodC and nifH gene analysis reveals a close phylogenetic relationship among Phaseolus vulgaris symbionts[J].Microbiology,2001,147(4):981-993
[31]Wang ET,van Berkum V,Beyene D,et al.Rhizobium huautlense sp.nov.,a symbiont of Sesbania herbacea that has a close phylogenetic relationship with Rhizobium galegae[J].International Journal of Systematic Bacteriology,1998,48(3):687-699
[32]Yoon SH,Ha SM,Kwon S,et al.Introducing ezbiocloud:a taxonomically united database of 16S rRNA gene sequences and whole-genome assemblies[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2017,67(5):1613-1617
[33]Tamura K,Peterson D,Peterson N,et al.MEGA5:molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood,evolutionary distance,and maximum parsimony methods[J].Molecular Biology and Evolution,2011,28(10):2731-2739
[34]Shetta ND,Alshahranil TS.The symbiotic efficiency of legume tree rhizobia for host range legumes in central Saudi Arabia[J].International Journal of Agriculture&Biology,2016,18(4):851-857
[35]Zaied KA,Kosba ZA,Nassef MA,et al.Induction of Rhizobium inoculants harboring salicylic acid gene[J].Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences,2009,3(2):1386-1411
[36]Tang Z,An H,Deng L,et al.Effect of desertification on productivity in a desert steppe[J].Scientific Reports,2016,6:27839
[37]Boukhatem ZF,Domergue O,Bekki A,et al.Symbiotic characterization and diversity of rhizobia associated with native and introduced acacias in arid and semi-arid regions in Algeria[J].FEMS Microbiology Ecology,2012,80(3):534-547
[38]Sachs JL,Kembel SW,Lau AH,et al.In situ phylogenetic structure and diversity of wild Bradyrhizobium communities[J].Applied Environmental Microbiology,2009,75(14):4727-4735
[39]Mengoni A,Pini F,Huang LN,et al.Plant-by-plant variations of bacterial communities associated with leaves of the nickel hyperaccumulator Alyssum bertolonii desv[J].Microbial Ecology,2009,58(3):660-667
[40]Arnold AE.Understanding the diversity of foliar endophytic fungi:progress,challenges,and frontiers[J].Fungal Biology Reviews,2007,21(2/3):51-66
[41]Nandwani R,Dudeja SS.Molecular diversity of a native Mesorhizobial population of nodulating chickpea(Cicer arietinum L.)in Indian soils[J].Journal of Basic Microbiology,2009,49(5):463-470
[42]Leite J,Fischer D,Rouws LFM,et al.Cowpea nodules harbor non-rhizobial bacterial communities that are shaped by soil type rather than plant genotype[J].Frontiers in Plant Science,2017,7:2064
[43]Gnat S,Wójcik M,Wdowiak-Wróbel S,et al.Phenotypic characterization of Astragalus glycyphyllos symbionts and their phylogeny based on the 16S rDNA sequences and RFLP of 16Sr RNA gene[J].Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek,2014,105(6):1033-1048
[44]Wielbo J,Marek-Kozaczuk M,Mazur A,et al.Genetic and metabolic divergence within a Rhizobium leguminosarum bv.trifolii population recovered from clover nodules[J].Applied and Environmental Microbiology,2010,76(14):4593-4600
[45]Wielbo J,Marek-Kozaczuk M,Mazur A,et al.The structure and metabolic diversity of population of pea microsymbionts isolated from root nodules[J].British Microbiology Research Journal,2011,1(3):55-69
[46]Wielbo J.Rhizobial communities in symbiosis with legumes:genetic diversity,competition and interactions with host plants[J].Central European Journal of Biology,2012,7(3):363-372
[47]Tindall BJ.The genus name Sinorhizobium chen et al.1988 is a later synonym of Ensifer casida 1982 and is not conserved over the latter genus name,and the species name‘Sinorhizobium adhaerens’is not validly published.opinion 84[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2008,58(Pt 8):1973
[48]Wang XL,Cui WJ,Feng XY,et al.Rhizobia inhabiting nodules and rhizosphere soils of alfalfa:a strong selection of facultative microsymbionts[J].Soil Biology and Biochemistry,2018,116:340-350
[49]Amadou C,Pascal G,Mangenot S,et al.Genome sequence of theβ-rhizobium Cupriavidus taiwanensis and comparative genomics of rhizobia[J].Genome Research,2008,18(9):1472-1483
[50]Estrella MJ,Munoz S,Soto MJ,et al.Genetic diversity and host range of rhizobia nodulating Lotus tenuis in typical soils of the Salado River Basin(Argentina)[J].Applied and Environmental Microbiology,2009,75(4):1088-1098
[51]Beijerinck MW,van Delden A.Ueber die Assimilation des freien Stickstoffs durch Bakterien[J].Zentbl Bakt Parasitenk Infekt,1902,2:3-43
[52]Tindall BJ.Agrobacterium radiobacter(Beijerinck and van Delden 1902)Conn 1942 has priority over Agrobacterium tumefaciens(Smith and Townsend 1907)Conn 1942 when the two are treated as members of the same species based on the principle of priority and Rule 23a,Note 1 as applied to the corresponding specific epithets.Opinion 94[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2014,64(Pt 10):3590-3592
[53]Conn HJ.Validity of the genus Alcaligenes[J].Journal of Bacteriology,1942,44(3):353-360
[54]Young JM,Pennycook SR,Watson DRW.Proposal that Agrobacterium radiobacter has priority over Agrobacterium tumefaciens.Request for an opinion[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2006,56(2):491-493
[55]Kaur J,Verma M,Lal R.Rhizobium rosettiformans sp.nov.,isolated from a hexachlorocyclohexane dump site,and reclassification of Blastobacter aggregatus Hirsch and Muller1986 as Rhizobium aggregatum comb.nov.[J].International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology,2011,61(Pt 5):1218-1225
[56]Burbano CS,Liu Y,R?sner KL,et al.Predominant nifH transcript phylotypes related to Rhizobium rosettiformans in field-grown sugarcane plants and in Norway spruce[J].Environmental Microbiology Reports,2011,3(3):383-389
[57]Fortuna MA,Zaman L,Ofria C,et al.The genotype-phenotype map of an evolving digital organism[J].PLoS Computational Biology,2017,13(2):e1005414
[58]Salazar-Ciudad I,Marín-Riera M.Adaptive dynamics under development-based genotype-phenotype maps[J].Nature,2013,497(7449):361-364
[59]Fridgen JL,Varco JJ.Dependency of cotton leaf nitrogen,chlorophyll,and reflectance on nitrogen and potassium availability[J].Agronomy Journal,2004,96(1):63-69
[60]Martínez-Romero E.Coevolution in rhizobium-legume symbiosis?[J].DNA and Cell Biology,2009,28(8):361-370
[61]Doyle JJ.Phylogenetic perspectives on the origins of nodulation[J].Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions,2011,24(11):1289-1295